Tennessee Highway Patrol Settles Ex-Wild Orchid Member’s Sober DUI Lawsuit for $70,000

The Tennessee Highway Patrol will pay $70,000 to Stephanie Fair, a former member of the 1990s pop group Wild Orchid, to settle her lawsuit over a DUI arrest that blood tests later proved was baseless, WSMV reported.

The state Board of Claims approved the settlement and a spokesman for the attorney general’s office said the payout should arrive in the next few weeks. Fair is the second sober driver to sue the patrol and reach a settlement, following a $75,000 payment to Thomas Manis after troopers in East Tennessee arrested him for DUI while he was sober.

The cases are piling up. Court records show multiple lawsuits from sober drivers now pending against the state, several naming a single trooper, James Zahn, who is accused of arresting nine sober drivers for DUI. NASA employee Labreesha Batey and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant are among those suing after first telling their stories to WSMV4 Investigates’ “Sobering Problem” series.

Troopers sued arresting sober driver

“I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable and that if they went to a jury trial, a jury would find against them,” said Ben Raybin, Fair’s attorney.

The arrest that sparked the suit

Fair’s arrest unfolded after a trooper claimed he smelled alcohol. “There’s a very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle,” the trooper said, according to video obtained by WSMV.

“But on my life, I don’t drink alcohol,” Fair responded. Footage shows her eating ice cream before the stop. “I was more scared being with that cop alone than I actually was inside the jail,” she told WSMV.

Tennessee Highway Patrol to pay $70,000 to settle lawsuit from sober driver arrested for DUI — WSMV 4 Nashville

Blood work later confirmed Fair had no alcohol in her system. Tennessee offers no administrative path for sober drivers to recoup legal costs or clear their records after a DUI charge is dismissed, Raybin said, leaving a civil lawsuit as the only remedy.

A pattern across agencies

The problem extends beyond the Highway Patrol. Court records show the Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office and the La Vergne Police Department have also settled lawsuits from sober drivers arrested for DUI. WSMV4 Investigates found Bondurant was the eighth sober driver Zahn arrested; a lawsuit filed this year by a Thompson Station man would make him the ninth.

What remains unresolved

The lawsuits against Zahn and the other pending cases have not yet gone to trial.