Tennessee Lookout Issues ‘Niceley Awards’ for Midterm Campaigns

Two weeks after the midterms, Tennessee politics is still picking through the wreckage, and the Tennessee Lookout has filed its first post-election edition of the Niceley Awards.

The tongue-in-cheek honor, named for the late Sen. Frank Niceley — who died in 2025 after a career spent equating toll roads with fascism, defending cockfighting, and once citing Adolf Hitler as a role model for people experiencing homelessness — usually wraps a legislative session.

This year, the Lookout applied the standard to the campaign trail, where the dust has barely settled on a May special session that redrew the 9th Congressional District to favor Republicans after nearly 50 years of Democratic control.

GOP state Sen. Brent Taylor won the seat on Nov. 3 despite an October surprise that arrived via his own phone. Nashville Scene writer Eli Motycka had a tip that Taylor, as recently as 2021, allegedly sent unsolicited nude photos to at least one woman.

The woman, who requested anonymity, no longer had the images, and Taylor was not in office at the time. The tip might have died there, but Taylor picked up Motycka’s call and, as the Lookout put it, “once he started talking, he couldn’t stop.”

Tennessee Lookout Issues 'Niceley Awards' for Midterm Campaigns
Photo: yahoo.com

“Men of faith — let alone men who are married, in their fifties, and in public office — have no business sending unsolicited nude photos to women.”

Democratic state Rep. Justin Pearson, Taylor’s opponent, issued a statement saying, “Men of faith — let alone men who are married, in their fifties, and in public office — have no business sending unsolicited nude photos to women.”

Taylor, 51 at the time of the alleged incident, called the photos a “youthful indiscretion” in an interview with conservative radio host Matt Murphy on 99.7 Supertalk, then admitted to sending them in conversations with Action 5 News in Memphis and the Memphis Flyer. The fallout may outlast the race: newly elected Democratic Rep. Jesse Huseth told the Lookout he plans to file “cyberflashing” legislation when the General Assembly gavels in this January.

The camo war in the 7th District

Further east, the race for Congressional District 7 produced a skirmish over yard signs. Democratic nominee Darden Copeland added a muted brown hunting camouflage design to his standard blue signs. Republican incumbent U.S. Rep. Matt Van Epps, a former Army helicopter pilot, raised the issue on NewsChannel 5’s “Inside Politics,” implying Copeland was running different campaigns in Nashville versus rural Dickson County.

“It has absolutely triggered my opponent,” Copeland told the Lookout. His campaign manager, Kevin Teets, said the camo signs were available district-wide, and the team leaned into Van Epps’ frustration for social media content, arguing a sitting congressman had larger concerns. Van Epps edged out a win; the camouflage, the Lookout noted, likely wasn’t the cause.

Pinkston posts video framing Jackson as trauma survivor

Independent gubernatorial candidate Lauren Pinkston, a former Lipscomb University professor, posted a video from Andrew Jackson’s Jonesborough home on Sept. 22 billing it as her “hottest Andrew Jackson take.” Jackson, the architect of the Indian Removal Act that ethnically cleansed five tribes, is a staple of Tennessee controversy.

Pinkston framed the seventh president as a trauma survivor: “When you have a lot of trauma and you don’t know how to process it, you end up doing things that are very risky and actually sometimes very harmful to other people.” The video came down after social media backlash, but the internet, as the Lookout observed, lives forever.

The General Assembly returns in January with new members and, if the Niceley Awards are any guide, no shortage of material.