The Branford Planning and Zoning Commission continued its fifth public hearing Thursday on a proposal to build a 106,700-square-foot BJ’s Wholesale Club off East Main Street near Interstate 95’s Exit 56, with at least 106 people participating via Zoom and 23 additional residents speaking. The commission agreed to hire an independent economic expert to analyze the project’s fiscal impact after opponents argued the store would divert business from existing retailers rather than generate new revenue.
PZC Chairman Charles Andres said he hopes to close the hearing at the commission’s regular meeting on Dec. 10 at 7 p.m. on Zoom. The hearing began Oct. 1 and has spanned sessions on Oct. 15, an in-person meeting Oct. 29, and Zoom sessions Nov. 5 and Nov. 19, New Haven Register reported.
Traffic and drainage debated
BJ’s engineer Kevin Solli of Solli Engineering in Oxford spent much of Thursday’s session responding to experts hired by two intervenors: Branford Citizens for Responsible Development and the Branford Land Trust. Solli argued the development would not adversely affect area roads, the drainage system, or nearby inland wetlands and watercourses including Van Wie Pond, the Branford River and Long Island Sound.
The property drains into two watersheds — the Branford River drainage basin on the west side and the South Central Shoreline drainage basin on the east — and Solli said storm drainage from the site would be minuscule compared to total basin flows.
Attorney Seth Klaskin, representing Branford Citizens for Responsible Development, countered that Solli “is distracting you by giving you these large numbers and saying, ‘We’re just a drop in the bucket’ … He’s only telling half the story.”
Michael Leone, attorney for the Branford Land Trust, said the developers “made the representation in their application that there is going to be no measurable impact. I don’t believe that they’ve met that burden.” He added: “Our point is, we don’t know what we don’t now, and it’s unarguable that there’s going to be more water flow from this property. They’re paving 15.5 acres that aren’t paved right now … So there is going to be an environmental impact to the Branford Land Trust and their Van Wie Pond … We just need to be assured that our property is going to be protected.”
Economic impact questioned
The commission’s decision to seek an independent economic analyst followed testimony from Fred Carstensen, a professor of finance and economics at the University of Connecticut and director of the Connecticut Center for Economic Analysis. Speaking at the Oct. 29 session, Carstensen said “retail is never economic development. Retail simply moves dollars around. Every gallon of gas that goes in there is going to come from somewhere else.”
Carstensen, who said he was neither for nor against the application, added that a proposal like BJ’s “generally does not increase the value of the grand list … There is no strong case to be made, quantitatively either in favor or against. You should focus on qualitative issues.”
At Thursday’s hearing, Klaskin called Carstensen “one of the foremost economists in the state of Connecticut” and noted he had since appeared before the Branford Economic Development Commission and issued reports. But Marjorie Shansky, attorney for the applicants, objected that “to the extent that he represented himself as an opponent, it would not be appropriate to pick him as a peer reviewer.”
Residents split on need and character
About 67 people spoke at previous meetings and roughly 200 have submitted emails, according to the Register.
Many speakers Thursday opposed the zone change required for the planned development district.
“Do we need another big-box store in Branford? My opinion is no,” said Daniel Rabin, a Short Beach resident of more than 40 years. “What would be the best use of the land? First Costco and now BJ’s are presented to us, as if it’s a binary choice … maybe a solar field, maybe some other kind of facility that would benefit … the people of Branford.”
“There is no economic advantage to the town by allowing retail development at this site … It may decrease revenue … It is inconsistent with Branford’s current character,” said Kathy Salisbury. “Therefore, I am strongly opposed to changing the zoning regulations in favor of this development.”
Linda Cummings said she is “just very concerned with building larger and larger structures … Bigger is not better. I would rather have structures that promote community engagement and the perpetuation of small businesses, not large businesses.”
Amanda Kass, a Thimble Island Road resident with a PhD in urban planning and policy who serves as research director for a national nonprofit, said the developer is seeking “a major policy change, yet I don’t think it provides any significant community benefits. I’m really surprised that there is no independent fiscal analysis.”
Bob Babcock said: “When someone comes in and they want to change the (Plan of Conservation & Development) … there should be overwhelming joy to have the application come to this town … Why should we change for something people do not want. To me, it makes no sense.”
Karen Kernan of Leetes Island Road said she was “really moved listening to this whole meeting right now. I just feel like I’m witnessing people participating in democracy. My big question is why? Why? Is Branford desperate? Who is really benefiting other than the landlord and BJ’s? Is Branford benefiting?”
Supporters cite family savings
Todd Petrowski, who also spoke Oct. 29, was among the few voices in favor. He said the intervenors “as far as I’m concerned, wasted numerous hours of the commission’s time. Most of their concerns belong at Inland Wetlands, not in a hearing about a proposed planned development district.”
“I’m for this project. I think it’s going to help the families in this town … If families … can save a couple of dollars, I think that’s a good thing for the town,” Petrowski said.
Project scope
In addition to the wholesale club, the application from Sound Development Group LLC and BJ’s Wholesale Club Inc. includes a 16-pump gas station, a 7,600-square-foot sit-down restaurant, two 2,800-square-foot quick-serve restaurants with drive-through lanes, and a 16,000-square-foot retail strip with a drive-through at one end. The nearly 40-acre site at 569 and 573 East Main St. is owned by former Hilltop Orchards co-owner Wayne Cooke and sits behind the Super Stop & Shop on Leetes Island Road — the same property where a Costco proposal failed a decade ago.
The next hearing session is scheduled for Dec. 10 at 7 p.m. on Zoom.