The holiday season usually brings a spike in generosity, but a workshop in Cheyenne on Thursday laid bare the other side of that coin: fraud losses reported nationwide hit nearly $21 billion in 2025, a 26 percent jump from the year before.
Victoria Curtis, a JPMorgan Chase community manager who oversees Wyoming, told the gathering that more than one million complaints were filed last year, with an average reported loss of nearly $21,000. The real toll is almost certainly higher.
“Imagine how many people don’t report for whatever reason, whether they don’t think it’s important, maybe they feel ashamed that they engaged with the scam, maybe they’re embarrassed, maybe they’re fearful,” Curtis said. “Maybe someone told them it wasn’t worth it.”
The weather-driven con
Will Young, who works in the Attorney General’s Consumer Protection and Antitrust Unit, said his office fields roughly 100 consumer complaints a month, many tied to home-improvement scams that follow hail events. The pitch is rehearsed: a crew claims to have leftover asphalt from a Wyoming Department of Transportation job and offers to pave a driveway on the spot — at a discount — because the material would otherwise be dumped.

“They’ll say, ‘Hey, we have leftover asphalt from a (Wyoming Department of Transportation) job,’” Young said. “‘We’re looking to drop it right now. We either have to put it down on your driveway or we’re going to have to dump it and just call it a loss.’”
The urgency is manufactured; the work is shoddy; the crew moves to the next state before the victim can recover a dime.
Paralegal warns of social-media ad scams
Amanda Swift, a paralegal in the same unit, said social-media ads are another steady source of complaints. She urged residents to research products independently and buy from known retailers rather than clicking linked ads. Investigator Paul Schoenfeld illustrated the point with his own near-miss: a $7,000 trailer listed online with no verifiable address. The seller claimed a Washington state registration; a quick check of the Secretary of State’s business registry showed the name belonged to a nonprofit with no connection to trailer sales.
“I contacted that business via email that they had listed, and they said, ‘No, we’re not associated with this trailer sale place at all,’” Schoenfeld said. “Matter of fact, the business name they gave me was a nonprofit. So that was a red flag right away. I just did a little bit of research, and a little bit of due diligence on my part saved me $7,000.”
Romance scams, meanwhile, are bleeding into younger demographics. Cheyenne Police Detective Audrey McGraw said the hook often starts with a comment on a profile picture.
“Romance scams are hard because there’s a lot of emotions involved, so it’s kind of hard to peel people away from that and get them to look at some of the red flags,” McGraw said. She also warned of sextortion schemes on platforms like Snapchat, where teens are pressured for intimate images and then threatened with distribution unless they pay.
Impersonation gets industrial
AARP volunteer and fraud investigator Tracy Griffith Swaim described impersonation scams that now mimic law enforcement, government agencies, and bank fraud departments with unsettling precision. A recurring script: a fake jury-duty warrant demanding immediate payment via gift cards or cryptocurrency. Some of those calls, Swaim said, have been traced to incarcerated individuals running the operation from prison.
Curtis distilled the anatomy of almost every scam into four components: the caller pretends to represent a trusted organization; they present a problem or a prize; they manufacture urgency; and they demand payment through a specific, hard-to-trace channel — gift cards, wire transfers, crypto, or person-to-person apps like Venmo.
Her single most effective countermeasure is free and immediate: pause. “If we just pause and we think and go, ‘OK, why don’t I just call the office? Why don’t I just call the bank?’ Saying, ‘Thank you so much for this information. I’ll give you a call right back,’” Curtis said.
“Hang up, call a trusted number. … Just pausing and enabling the rational side of our brain. Give our emotional side a moment to collect ourselves.”
The Wyoming Department of Transportation, formed in 1991 by merging the Highway Department with aeronautics, revenue and public-service functions, employs nearly 2,000 people across about 60 sites. Its roots trace to 1917, when the Highway Department was created to meet the Federal Aid Road Act of 1916.
The agency first undertook large-scale winter snow removal in 1929 after buying 33 additional plows, and the Wyoming Highway Patrol was authorized on June 1, 1933, remaining affiliated with the department ever since.
Officials also recommended reviewing bank transactions regularly, setting up account alerts, using strong unique passwords rotated every few months, and enabling biometric authentication. Victims or targets should contact local law enforcement, file a report with the Federal Trade Commission, and reach out to the Wyoming Attorney General’s Office for help vetting suspicious offers.