- Woodside Energy sold its 33.4% stake in Greater Sunrise to Timor-Leste last month, leaving the government with near-total control.
- Timor-Leste has already spent nearly $2 billion on infrastructure and buyouts for a project analysts call commercially unviable.
- Petroleum Minister Francisco da Costa Monteiro says companies from China, Russia, Japan, Europe and the U.S. have expressed interest since Woodside’s exit.
- Analyst Saul Kavonic warns the project faces either “diabolical disaster” or forced cession of economic sovereignty to a geopolitical partner like China.
The Greater Sunrise field sits 500 kilometres north of Darwin in the Timor Sea and straddles the maritime boundary between Timor-Leste and Australia.
It holds an estimated 5 trillion cubic feet of gas and 360 million barrels of condensate. Woodside’s decision to sell its stake — reportedly for a nominal sum after prior write-downs — ends nearly two decades of Australian industry stewardship and places the development burden on a state budget that is described as “among the most constrained in the region.”
At a ceremony in Dili earlier this month, Prime Minister Xanana Gusmão launched a submarine to map the seafloor for a proposed pipeline to Timor’s southern coast. Petroleum Minister Francisco da Costa Monteiro told ABC News the project would proceed.
“We have no doubt the Greater Sunrise can be developed in the near future,” he said. “This field remains very attractive, not just for Timor-Leste, but also for the other potential players in the region and in the world.”
Unnamed suitors from China, Russia and beyond
Monteiro said unnamed companies from Russia, China, Europe, America and Japan had approached the government since Woodside’s departure. “We cannot say A-B-C, but certainly there’s companies in the region, as well as far as other parts of the world … in Europe, America, and in Russia, in China, in Japan. There are quite a number of parties we’ve been engaging,” he told ABC News.
MST Financial analyst Saul Kavonic said the Russian scenario was “unlikely” but identified China as one of the few pathways that could see the project succeed. “Because it’s uncommercial, the only country that would be interested in doing it would be doing it for geopolitical reasons,” he told ABC News. “That is one of the big concerns here, in that in its pursuit of trying to get this project done they ultimately have to resort to ceding part of their economic sovereignty to another nation like China.”
Commercial viability questioned
Kavonic said the field’s size was too small to stack up commercially. “It’s not big enough. It’s just not viable in any commercial basis … it’s not even close,” he told ABC News. “I really hope they prove my view — and that of many others in the industry who have similar views — wrong. Unfortunately I think there’s a very remote chance of that happening.”
All four major oil and gas companies previously involved in Greater Sunrise have now left the project, a fact Kavonic said highlighted its lack of commercial appeal. He warned the government’s insistence on piping gas to Timor rather than using the existing Darwin LNG infrastructure “threatens the ongoing viability of the nation going forward.”
Cost estimates diverge by billions
Development cost estimates vary sharply. A 2015 report put the cost of developing the project in Timor at $US20.5 billion ($29 billion), while a 2021 report commissioned by the Timor-Leste government estimated $US14.1 billion ($21.1 billion), according to ABC News. With labour and construction costs now “drastically more expensive,” most analysts expect the government would have to draw heavily on its sovereign wealth fund, which holds about $US18 billion ($27 billion) according to Timor’s central bank. The gas project that fed royalties into that fund is no longer operational.
The government says it aims to fund Greater Sunrise with 30 per cent equity and 70 per cent project finance. Marta Da Silva, head of local accountability organisation La’o Hamutuk, said the country risked falling off a “fiscal cliff” and criticised the government’s lack of transparency.
“The question [is] where the government is getting the money to fund this project?” she told ABC News. “With Greater Sunrise, we cannot only speak about [our] sovereignty as a country, but we must look at the economy, how viable [it is] and how the people can get the benefits from those industries.”
Worth a look