Author and Pulitzer finalist Tommy Orange visited Colorado College on November 9 to discuss the intersection of oral tradition, personal doubt, and the weight of history in his latest work.
The event, hosted in Armstrong Hall by the college’s Anti-Racist Book Club, featured readings from his 2024 novel Wandering Stars, a companion to his acclaimed debut, There.
The Catalyst reported that the discussion, moderated by English Professor Natanya Ann Pulley and Story Keepers Book Club founder Brittney Ann Maris, centered on how fiction can bridge the gap between historical record and lived experience. Orange’s recent novel traces the lineage of a fictional family over 150 years, anchoring its narrative in the 1864 Sand Creek Massacre, where the U.S. military slaughtered Arapaho and Cheyenne people in Colorado.
For Orange, the challenge of writing about such a traumatic event lies in reconciling academic historical accounts with the stories preserved within his own family. He said that while historical texts often focus on the gore of the massacre, the oral histories passed down to him carry a different, more poetic weight.
His objective, he explained, is not to dwell solely on the violence, but to honor the lives of those lost by inviting the reader to listen.
“The version they tell, you know, it’s not a gory version. There’s something poetic about it.”
said Orange. He emphasized that the act of storytelling serves as a vessel for this preservation, stating that the, “pain that sits in you un-languaged, the kind that remains unarticulated, is the kind that does the most damage.”
This perspective resonates deeply with the broader conversation surrounding the representation of Native communities in literature. Orange observed that when he shared early drafts of There, Native readers did not describe the narrative as merely “sad.”
Instead, they expressed a sense of recognition, seeing their own lives reflected in a medium that has historically excluded them. He argued that there is a fundamental disconnect in how industries perceive the necessity and function of Native stories.
According to Orange, the path to universal appeal is found through radical specificity. By focusing on contemporary, granular details of a Native person’s life, he finds that the resulting story transcends cultural boundaries, creating a paradox where the hyper-specific becomes the universal. This approach challenges common publishing industry assumptions that Native narratives must fit into narrow, pre-defined boxes to reach a wide audience.
The conversation also shifted to the internal mechanics of his craft, specifically his relationship with self-doubt. Orange maintains an open-door policy regarding his drafts, often sharing unfinished or “embarrassing” work with friends and family to gauge its resonance. He views doubt not as a hurdle to be cleared, but as a functional tool for revision that ultimately strengthens the final product.
“It’s not necessarily getting better with self-doubt, but I also had to make friends with doubt and understand that it’s part of a tool in revision that makes your writing better.”
Orange told the audience. He encouraged young writers to prioritize collaborative writing and consistent practice, urging educators to help students identify the specific stories they feel compelled to tell and, more importantly, to understand the motivations behind that compulsion.
The stakes of this work extend beyond the pages of a novel. For communities whose histories have been systematically marginalized by official records, the act of writing becomes a reclamation of agency. By grounding his fiction in the specific, unvarnished realities of his characters, Orange is participating in a larger effort to ensure that Native experiences are not just recorded, but understood as integral to the American narrative.
As he continues work on his third novel and a forthcoming memoir, Orange remains focused on the power of language to transform unarticulated pain into shared understanding. The event concluded with a look toward future projects, marking a continuation of his commitment to documenting the lineage of survival and the complexities of identity in modern America.