TPPF Sues Over Forest Service Wilderness Filming Restrictions

The Texas Public Policy Foundation filed a federal lawsuit on November 18 challenging the U.S. Forest Service’s enforcement of restrictions that prohibit monetizing video filmed in designated wilderness areas, the organization announced.

The complaint, lodged in the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming on behalf of Wyoming resident Joshua Smunk and the BlueRibbon Coalition, argues the agency has exceeded its statutory authority and violated the First Amendment by regulating speech based on whether it generates revenue.

The case, Smunk and BlueRibbon Coalition, Inc. v. Kenneth Coffin, William Frost, and United States Forest Service, centers on a September 2025 elk hunting trip in Wyoming’s Shoshone National Forest.

While camped in a designated wilderness area, members of Smunk’s hunting party recorded a conversation. Pack llamas from Smunk’s outdoor recreation business appeared in the background. The video was later posted to YouTube and monetized, though Smunk neither published the footage nor earned revenue from it, according to the BlueRibbon Coalition.

They also indicated the agency monitors social media for potential violations and pursues enforcement against people who post such content.

“Monetized speech is entitled to the same constitutional protection as non-monetized speech.”

The lawsuit cites the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2015 decision in Reed v. They further contend the Forest Service lacks statutory authority to regulate publishing and monetizing activity that takes place outside wilderness boundaries.

Congress updated permitting rules for filming on federal lands in the EXPLORE Act, signed into law on January 4, 2025, but left the Wilderness Act’s prohibition on commercial enterprise in place within designated wilderness.

“Americans have every right to document their time on public lands and share it with others,” said Ben Burr, executive director of BlueRibbon Coalition. “The First Amendment protects that speech whether or not it earns a dime.”

The Texas Public Policy Foundation, a conservative think tank co-founded in 1989 by James R. Leininger and Fritz S. Steiger, moved from San Antonio to Austin in 2003 to operate near the state capitol. It opened a Washington, D.C., office in 2018 to expand its federal policy work and today runs a litigation arm alongside nine issue-area centers.

The organization sponsors the Right on Crime initiative, which seeks to reduce incarceration through sentencing reforms, and its States Trust project promotes shifting authority from the federal government to the states in areas such as energy regulation.

The plaintiffs seek declaratory and injunctive relief barring the Forest Service from enforcing the restrictions.