Twice-Deported Driver Charged in Crash Killing University of New Haven Hockey Captain Ryan O’Shea

Guillermo Carmona-Lopez, 31, was charged Monday with second-degree manslaughter and driving under the influence in the death of University of New Haven hockey captain Ryan O’Shea, 21, after a wrong-way crash on Interstate 91 in North Haven on Oct. 16.

The collision has drawn federal attention because Carmona-Lopez, a Mexican citizen living in Bridgeport, had been deported twice in 2013 and re-entered the United States on an unknown date, according to the Department of Homeland Security. He was driving with a suspended license and a blood-alcohol level nearly three times the legal limit when his pickup truck struck O’Shea’s Honda Accord head-on around 11:45 p.m., state police said.

A cascade of failures

Carmona-Lopez lost his Connecticut license in May 2024 after a DUI arrest, according to the arrest warrant. Five months later, he told investigators from his hospital bed that he had consumed four glasses of Modelo beer after finishing painting and cleaning jobs in New Haven.

He said he believed he was entering Interstate 95 from a New Haven on-ramp but could not remember which one. “Once he got on the highway he did not remember anything after that,” the warrant says.

Twice-Deported Driver Charged in Crash Killing University of New Haven Hockey Captain Ryan O'Shea
Photo: thehour.com

Two blood tests at Yale New Haven Hospital showed alcohol concentrations of 0.22 and 0.21. Connecticut’s legal limit is 0.08.

The impact pushed O’Shea’s Accord into the left-center lane, where it was struck by an SUV, then into the right lane and shoulder, where another SUV hit it. O’Shea, a criminal justice major from Stony Point, N.Y., was pronounced dead at the scene. Two other drivers and a passenger suffered minor injuries. Carmona-Lopez was hospitalized with serious, life-threatening injuries.

Border Patrol arrests Carmona-Lopez multiple times

Border Patrol agents first arrested Carmona-Lopez in May 2013 after he entered the country illegally, according to Immigration and Customs Enforcement. An expedited removal order was issued and he was removed.

He re-entered illegally near the Rio Grande Valley later that same month and was arrested again. A Justice Department immigration judge issued a final removal order on May 30, 2013. ICE says he re-entered at least one more time, at an unknown location on an unknown date.

“His family should be celebrating his accomplishments and looking forward to his future,” acting Director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement David J. Venturella said in a news release. “Instead, they’re mourning a life tragically cut short.”

DHS called the collision “a completely avoidable tragedy” and said it would continue efforts to prevent “more Angel Families,” a term used for relatives of people killed by individuals in the country illegally.

A leader on and off the ice

O’Shea was a member of the Class of 2027 and a co-captain of the men’s club hockey team. His obituary noted he served as president of the Kappa Sigma fraternity, “where he enjoyed recruiting new students and welcoming them into the brotherhood.”

The team retired his jersey at a pregame ceremony at Northford Ice Pavilion before its first game since his death, against Wentworth Institute of Technology — the first jersey retirement in program history.

Carmona-Lopez is being held on $500,000 bond and is scheduled to appear Dec. 1 in state Superior Court in Meriden.