Fr. Daniel Ciucci announced on Monday that he will take a sabbatical before a likely reassignment in July, ending a tenure at Most Precious Blood Catholic Church that began in the summer of 2021 and grew increasingly strained after a group of parishioners formally petitioned the archbishop for his removal.
In a 15-minute video posted to his YouTube channel, Ciucci said he met with Archbishop James R. Golka in June and, overcome with emotion, acknowledged he had been “carrying a pain” stemming from pastoral friction and reactions to his “proclamation of the gospel,” particularly on Catholic moral teaching.
The archbishop offered the sabbatical for a “self-examine of my priesthood,” including a 30-day Ignatian retreat and a walk on the Camino de Santiago, with a view toward a new parish assignment next summer.
“I hold no animosity against anyone,” Ciucci said in the video. He urged parishioners to welcome his successor as a friend and reminded them the parish “had never been about me but rather Our Lord.”
The rupture traces back to July 2024, when the MPB Community Group launched an online petition addressed to then-Archbishop Samuel Aquila. The petition warned that “parishioners, and parents [of the parish school] do not feel empowered or comfortable sharing concerns for fear of retribution or feedback falling on deaf ears.” It requested a formal listening session, a pastoral review, and interim support while a long-term solution was discerned.
By August 8, 2025, the group reported that the archdiocese had “chosen to dismiss the substance of what we have raised, offering instead blanket praise for Fr. Daniel Ciucci and implying that the serious issues we’ve documented are merely ‘strong feelings’ or misunderstandings,” according to AdVaticanum. The group called the response “unacceptable” and urged members to write to the archbishop and “prepare for more action.”

Tensions spilled into the pulpit. In an August 2025 homily titled “Why Hell Is Welcoming,” delivered weeks after the petition went public, Ciucci told the congregation, “This parish, to put it bluntly, has had a history of putting community or other such things as an idol. We cannot put community before God himself. I’ve been vilified for repeatedly making this point.”
He added that critics found the parish “no longer welcoming because Father Daniel or Father Micah bring up sin which is so outdated and pessimistic and joy-killing.”
Addressing the petition directly from the altar, he said it had “broken open now the real conversation” — a conversation, he argued, about “the fact that people get offended that they need to be saved by Jesus and the implications of why Jesus became man why Jesus founded a church, why Peter was made hierarchy of that church, and how that governance exists today for the sake of salvation.”
At an August parish meeting this year, Ciucci pushed back on rumors of an imminent transfer. “Any claim that I have already been reassigned is conjecture at best,” he said, adding, “I have not asked for reassignment.”
He acknowledged “people may have a number of different thoughts about whether I should remain as pastor,” but insisted he serves “here or anywhere at the good pleasure of the archbishop of Denver.” He also warned against gossip, calling it “really unfortunate, but it is not uncommon in communities.”
Ciucci’s first pastorate followed service at St. John the Baptist in Longmont. At his installation Mass, he told the congregation, “it will be you my beloved parish who will teach me how to love as a Father,” and asked for patience as he grew into the role.
Weeks after arriving, he celebrated Mass outside a Planned Parenthood facility on the Feast of St. Maximilian Kolbe, taking a public stance that would later become a flashpoint.
The parish, which operates a school serving children from preschool through eighth grade, offers Mass ten times a week. A 2017–2018 Knights of Columbus directory listed 1,444 registered families. The school welcomes Catholic and non-Catholic families alike, with parish-connected students receiving a large tuition discount. Pupils attend weekly Mass, begin and end each day with prayer, and participate in Eucharistic adoration and the rosary.
No successor has been named. The archdiocese has not released a public statement on the sabbatical or the pending reassignment.