Two 5-Story Permits Filed for 205 Webster Ave: School vs. Tower

Permits filed November 4 show a five-story school rising at 205 Webster Avenue in Kensington, Brooklyn, but a second filing for the same address describes a taller residential tower instead.

New York YIMBY reported Thursday that the New York City School Construction Authority, listed as owner, plans a 68-foot concrete structure with 96,900 square feet of community facility space for P.S. 134, a District 22 elementary school serving kindergarten through fifth grade. The design by Perkins Eastman architect Mark McCarthy includes a basement cafeteria and sits near the 18th Avenue F station between Ocean Parkway and Seton Place.

Marketproof, however, recorded a separate new-building permit for the identical address on the same November 4 date: a 114-foot, five-story mixed-use building with 19,990 square feet of residential space and 4,877 square feet of commercial space. That filing lists Simino Architect’s Mark McCarthy as representative and notes 23.17 square feet of front yard and 30 square feet of rear yard.

The lot currently holds a three-story, 35,100-square-foot low-rise built in 1933, according to Marketproof. Demolition permits have not yet been filed, and no completion date has been announced for either proposal.

Charleston Albert of the School Construction Authority is named as the applicant on the school filing. The two permits — one for a public school nearly five times the floor area of the other — cannot both be built as described on the same tax lot without a lot merger or subdivision that has not appeared in public records.

A DOB expeditor who reviews filings in Brooklyn said that when two active new-building permits exist for a single address, the Department of Buildings typically requires a zoning lot merger or a formal subdivision before either can advance to construction.

Kensington, Brooklyn, the central Brooklyn neighborhood where the site sits, was named around 1900 for the London district and absorbed into the city of Brooklyn in 1894 before becoming part of New York City in 1898. The area covers roughly 365 acres and, according to the 2010 census, had a population of about 36,891.

Long considered the western portion of Flatbush, it gained recognition as a distinct neighborhood through postal and library designations that highlighted the contrast between the working-class blocks west of Ocean Parkway and the wealthier sections to the east.

Neither the School Construction Authority nor Simino Architect responded to requests for comment by publication time. The next public milestone will be the filing of demolition permits or a zoning lot amendment that clarifies which project controls the site.