Two St. Albans Teens Charged in Burlington Church Street Assault, Robbery

Two 18-year-old men from St. Albans face felony charges after a downtown Burlington dispute erupted into a pistol-whipping incident on a busy Tuesday afternoon, WCAX reported.

Officers with the Burlington Police Department rushed to Church Street near Bank Street at approximately 4:08 p.m. following emergency calls reporting an individual brandishing a firearm.

The victim told investigators that one of the suspects struck him directly in the head with a gun while a second accomplice stripped him of personal property. The confrontation left the victim with minor injuries before both assailants retreated to a waiting vehicle and fled the scene at high speed.

Investigators quickly identified the suspects as Noah Myott and Fourbear Bailey, both 18 and residents of St. Albans. Police arrested both young men on Wednesday, recovering a replica BB gun during the ensuing property searches and seizing it as physical evidence, according to local filings.

2 teens charged in Church Street assault and robbery — WCAX Channel 3 News

Myott and Bailey appeared in court on Thursday to face their respective charges before local judges. Myott was formally charged with assault and robbery alongside an additional count of negligent operation of a motor vehicle. Bailey faced a single charge of assault and robbery.

Both defendants entered pleas of not guilty during Thursday’s proceedings. Following their arraignment, the court released the teenagers under strict supervision conditions that mandate a continuous 24-hour curfew at their home in St. Albans, a strict prohibition against possessing dangerous weapons, and an order releasing them directly into the custody of their parents, MYNBC5 reported.

Church Street Marketplace, the open-air pedestrian mall spanning four blocks between Main and Pearl Streets in downtown Burlington, draws thousands daily to its roughly 86 storefronts, restaurants and bars. Conceived in 1958, it was built in 1980–81 after a 1971 one-day street fair attracted about 15,000 people and a week-long 1972 fair drew an estimated 50,000, proving the concept. The American Planning Association named it one of America’s “Great Public Spaces” in 2008.

Asphalt roadway and sidewalk between aged stone building exteriors with bright walls in town
Photo: vermontpost.com

Police have not yet detailed the exact nature of the stolen property, nor have investigators publicly clarified whether the recovered replica BB gun served as the actual weapon used to strike the victim during the daylight altercation. The investigation continues as authorities process evidence gathered from the downtown corridor.