The College Football Playoff selection committee released its third set of rankings Tuesday, keeping Alabama at No. 3 despite a résumé that has deteriorated in recent weeks.
USA Today reported the committee continues to favor the Southeastern Conference, though the league appears headed for a maximum of four bids — down from five a year ago — while showing skepticism toward teams built on defense, such as Indiana, Tennessee and BYU.
Ohio State climbed seven spots after a win over Northwestern, aided by losses from several ranked SEC teams. The Buckeyes' rise changes the rankings the committee will evaluate over the final two cycles.
“I’ve joined the rest of the country, outside of the Yellowhammer State, wondering why the Crimson Tide are ranked this high, especially after their resume worsened last weekend,” Blake Toppmeyer, columnist for USA Today Sports, said on the “College Football Unfiltered” podcast.
Alabama’s shaky perch at No. 3
Toppmeyer argued the committee is effectively treating Alabama as if it beat Georgia in October, ignoring that the Crimson Tide lost at home to the Bulldogs and were “boot-stomped” at Tennessee. Alabama’s signature wins — over LSU, Kentucky, South Carolina and Mississippi State — have lost luster as each of those opponents has stumbled.

“If the committee craves a two-loss team at No. 3, it should be Texas, not Alabama,” Toppmeyer said. “The Longhorns boast a superior resume.”
Texas sits at No. 4 with a stronger overall profile, including a road win at Michigan and a head-to-head victory over Tennessee that came down to the final play.
Defense-heavy teams penalized
The committee’s preference for explosive offenses has pushed Tennessee to No. 9 despite no bad losses and a dominant win over Alabama in Knoxville. Indiana checks in at No. 8 and BYU at No. 10, forming a cluster of defense-first teams the committee views warily.
BREAKING: ALABAMA REMAINS NO. 3 IN THE CFP RANKINGS 🏈 College Football Playoff Top 25 1. Georgia 2. Utah 3. Alabama 4. UCLA 5. Texas 6. Notre Dame 7. Miami 8. Indiana 9. Tennessee 10. BYU 11. Wake Forest 12. Texas Tech 13. Oregon 14. Ohio State 15. Iowa 16. Kentucky 17. Boise… pic.twitter.com/Bu08Lm017K
“It’s not a grand conspiracy,” Toppmeyer said. “Rather, the committee simply distrusts teams with middling offenses. That explains Indiana at No. 8, Tennessee at No. 9, and BYU at No. 10. Teams ahead of them have better offenses. The committee loves a good pass game.”
John Brice, college football insider for USA Today Sports, countered that Indiana’s defense “just does not take a week off” and said the Hoosiers deserved to be higher after beating Southern Cal.
“I said I’d sing a different tune about Indiana if it beat Southern Cal, and I’m sticking to my word. The Hoosiers have gone from overrated to underrated.”
— John Brice, USA Today Sports
Notre Dame and the offense argument
Brice also flagged Notre Dame at No. 6 as underrated, pointing to a blowout win over Boston College following a victory at Miami. The Irish face SMU next, and Brice argued a decisive win should vault them into the top five.
“The committee likes offense, you say? Well, CJ Carr should be a Heisman Trophy finalist, and Notre Dame just blasted Boston College after previously handling Miami, so why aren’t the Irish ranked higher?” Brice said.

Houston and Kentucky flagged as overrated
On the other end, Brice called for Houston’s removal from the rankings at No. 20 after Colorado gashed the Cougars for 65- and 75-yard touchdown runs in a 42-32 loss. Toppmeyer placed Kentucky at No. 16 as overrated, noting the Wildcats have lost three times and faded since an October peak.
“Kentucky was a neat story in October. In November, it’s not a top-20 team,” Toppmeyer said.
SEC bid ceiling comes into focus
The broader implication is an SEC bid ceiling of four, a notable contraction from the five teams the conference placed in the playoff a year ago. With Alabama, Georgia, Texas and Tennessee currently positioned for inclusion, teams like Ole Miss and Texas A&M face long odds unless chaos ensues in championship weekend.