Judge Rules Thomas Markle Mentally Competent to Stand Trial in Child Abuse Case

A Florida judge ruled Thursday that Thomas Markle Sr., 82, is mentally competent to stand trial on federal charges of possessing child sexual abuse material, rejecting the defense’s bid to halt proceedings over his dementia diagnosis.

The decision, delivered in a Tampa courtroom, clears the way for the case to move to Los Angeles, where prosecutors allege Markle kept 78 items — slides, film negatives and books — in two storage units rented since 2008, according to the FBI.

Some of the images appear to depict Markle himself with children, the bureau said, and witnesses identified the man in two of them as being in his 30s or 40s, suggesting the alleged abuse dates back decades.

Dr. Amie Gerodimos, the court-appointed psychiatrist, wrote in a 15-page report filed after a 90-minute interview at the Pinellas County Jail on November 12: “It is my opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr Markle is competent to stand trial.” She concluded he was “malingering” — exaggerating memory loss to avoid the proceedings. Markle’s lawyer did not contest the finding.

Meghan Markle's dad Thomas hit w/ abuse charges as William and Kate are in India — Page Six

“Why I am here. What have I done?” Markle told Gerodimos, according to her report cited by CBC. “I don’t have any child porn. I have no pictures of naked kids.” He also claimed his son, Thomas Markle Jr., was responsible for his legal troubles, telling the psychiatrist, “My son hates me. He has never accomplished anything.”

From Dementia Facility to Federal Custody

The arrest unfolded on November 6 at a Lakeland, Florida, assisted-living facility specializing in dementia care, where Markle had been living after a stroke and left-leg amputation forced his return from the Philippines earlier this year. He was initially released on bond but was taken back into custody on November 10 after authorities said he cut off his electronic ankle monitor.

Thomas Markle's police mugshot
Photo: BBC

Judge Lindsay S. Griffin had ordered the competency exam after Markle’s first appearance, writing that his “advanced age and lack of recall” gave “reasonable cause to believe that the defendant may presently suffer from a mental disease or defect.” Gerodimos’ evaluation reversed that assessment, noting Markle understood the charges and could assist counsel despite diagnosed cognitive issues.

During the interview, Markle at one point mistook his daughter Meghan, the Duchess of Sussex, for his sister, telling the evaluator, “I don’t think so. I have two kids. I think Meghan is Samantha. I only have one daughter and one son,” according to documents obtained by Page Six. He also said his “sister Meghan” could provide details on his medical history.

Parallel Investigation in the Philippines

The U.S. case was triggered by a discovery in Cebu City. Philippine police said Markle’s half-brother, Thomas Markle Jr., found child sexual abuse images while clearing their father’s home last month and turned over four boxes of devices — computers, phones, hard drives and video tapes — to authorities.

On Monday, the Philippine National Police’s Women and Children Protection Center filed a formal criminal complaint against Markle for possession and intent to distribute child sexual abuse material, Brigadier General Allen Rae Co confirmed to Reuters. The prosecutor’s office in Cebu is now assessing whether to bring charges.

Left: This booking photo, released by the Pinellas County Sheriff
Photo: CTV News

“There’s nothing incriminating” in the Philippines, Markle insisted to Gerodimos.

A Decade of Estrangement

Meghan Markle has been estranged from her father since 2018, when he did not attend her wedding to Prince Harry at Windsor Castle.

In a statement to People, the Duchess said she was “deeply distressed” by the allegations and confirmed that London’s Metropolitan Police had shared a letter with her in 2018 making “troubling and disturbing allegations” against Thomas Sr. She said she had been given assurances the matter was being investigated.

The BBC, citing sources close to the Duchess, reported she broke contact with him last year, telling him she and authorities knew he had abused young girls. “My thoughts are with any children who may have been harmed,” she wrote.

If convicted on the single U.S. count of possession of child pornography, Markle faces a statutory maximum of 20 years in federal prison, according to the Department of Justice. A future court date in California has not yet been set.

Thomas markle charges phillipines
Photo: Global News

— Dr. Amie Gerodimos, court-appointed psychiatrist, University of South Florida Health

“Why I am here. What have I done? I don’t have any child porn. I have no pictures of naked kids.”

— Thomas Markle Sr., during competency evaluation, per Dr. Gerodimos’ report