Six point three million people would lose food assistance in 2029 under a USDA proposed rule published November 10 that would end broad-based categorical eligibility for SNAP, ACHI reported.
The rule targets the mechanism 46 states and territories use to soften the federal program’s rigid income and asset tests.
By allowing households that receive a TANF-funded service to qualify for SNAP without meeting the federal 130 percent poverty-line gross income limit or the $3,000 asset cap, broad-based categorical eligibility has become the primary tool states use to prevent the “benefit cliff” that cuts families off the moment their earnings inch above the threshold.
“BBCE helps these families meet their basic needs,” Ben Ray Luján wrote in a November 13 letter to USDA signed by Senate Democrats. “The costs of housing, utilities, child care, health care, and other necessities are leaving working families and seniors on fixed incomes with little money left for food.”
The proposal would restrict categorical eligibility to households receiving TANF cash assistance, effectively dismantling the flexibility both Republican and Democratic governors have relied on.
Arkansas’s distinct model
Arkansas illustrates what the rule would unravel. Unlike most states, Arkansas kept the federal 130 percent gross income limit and the asset test — $3,000 for most households, $4,750 for those with an elderly or disabled member — but used a TANF-funded brochure to confer categorical eligibility.
That technical maneuver allowed the legislature to pass Act 675 of 2023, which created a temporary asset-limit increase to $5,500 for 12 consecutive months, no more than once every five years, so families could build modest savings without losing benefits.

Because the brochure is a non-cash TANF benefit, the proposed rule would eliminate the federal authority for that temporary increase, ACHI reported. Households currently covered by categorical eligibility would also have to pass the net income test — income after housing and childcare deductions at or below 100 percent of poverty — on top of the gross test they already face.
Cascading effects on schools and counties
The ripple effects extend beyond the SNAP case file. Children who lose SNAP eligibility could also lose direct certification for free school meals, though they could still qualify through Medicaid or income-based applications. Schools participating in the Community Eligibility Provision — which offers free meals to all students based on the share of directly certified children — could see their reimbursement rates drop or their eligibility threatened as the identified-student percentage falls.
County administrators, who run SNAP in ten states, warn the rule piles new verification work onto agencies already absorbing an increase in their share of administrative costs under H.R. 1, the 2025 budget reconciliation law.
“Without additional federal resources, this increase in workload is an unfunded mandate on local governments,” the National Association of Counties wrote in its November 10 analysis. NACo also said that most states use categorical eligibility to eliminate the asset test entirely; reinstating it would require households to provide additional financial verification, expanding paperwork and the potential for payment errors.
Error-rate pressure and the comment window
Arkansas is already under pressure: its payment error rate was nearly 9 percent in June, well above the 6 percent threshold that will trigger state benefit-cost sharing starting October 2027 under H.R. 1.
Public comments on the categorical-eligibility rule and a companion proposed rule tightening work requirements for able-bodied adults without dependents are due December 10. The work-requirement rule would bar states from combining contiguous counties to qualify for high-unemployment waivers, require 12 months of unemployment data instead of three, limit waivers to one year, and affirm the Secretary’s discretion to deny waivers even when economic conditions are met.
“This flexibility has been embraced by leaders of both parties and is now used in 43 states, the District of Columbia, Guam, and the U.S. Virgin Islands,” Luján’s letter states. “We urge USDA to withdraw the proposed rule in its entirety.”