“How does this man still have a job?” a source close to Utah athletics asked The Salt Lake Tribune, capturing the friction that has defined Mark Harlan’s eight years as athletic director.
That question hangs over a department where football is ascending yet internal division runs deep. The Utes won five Pac-12 titles and a skiing national championship in 2022-23, and fundraising has set records. But success has not silenced the criticism, Tribune columnist Gordon Monson reported after interviews with roughly a half-dozen trusted sources granted anonymity to protect their standing.
Harlan’s most public flashpoint came after the Utah-BYU football game two seasons ago. He ran onto the field to protest a late holding call, then told reporters the officials “stole” the game and said he was not proud to belong to the Big 12. The conference fined him $40,000. His apology arrived late and struck many as tepid.
The departure of Kyle Whittingham this offseason deepened the unease. Whittingham, the winningest coach in program history, left after a 10-2 season under pressure from the administration. The move cost Utah roughly $13 million in departure fees. Morgan Scalley has started strong as the new head coach, but the manner of the transition left scars among boosters, fans and department staff.
Men’s basketball tells a different story. The program has not reached the NCAA Tournament in a decade. Harlan fired Larry Krystkowiak, hired Craig Smith, fired Smith, then hired former Ute player and NBA assistant Alex Jensen before last season.
Jensen went 10-22 in year one, winning only two conference games. In a recent hourlong meeting with Monson and Jensen, the coach said he needs more resources — support, communication, a pathway to win. Harlan acknowledged the program is not where he wants it to be but insisted things will improve.
Sources say Jensen once secured a large booster gift and feared informing Harlan because the money might be redirected elsewhere. Trust, they say, is scarce. Jensen waved off that notion in the meeting. Harlan spoke like an administrator who wants nothing but success for the program.
Yet the discord persists. Some coaches and employees describe a management style that fuels division rather than unity.
Before Utah, Harlan spent five years as athletic director at the University of South Florida. A University of Arizona graduate with degrees in political science and education, he also held sports administration roles at UCLA, San Jose State and Northern Colorado.
In June 2023, after Utah earned its highest LEARFIELD Director’s Cup finish and a school-record 10 conference titles in 2022-23, he received a contract extension through 2028 and was named Cushman & Wakefield A.D. of the Year by NACDA.
The football rise continues. The basketball rebuild waits. And the question lingers.