Former Ireland international Shane Horgan has labelled Rassie Erasmus’s post-match conduct “Trumpian behaviour” and an “insidious campaign” that is “extremely damaging” to rugby’s integrity, The Irish Times reported.
The criticism follows Erasmus’s explosive press conference on Monday after South Africa’s Nations Championship defeat to France at the Stade de France, which resulted in a six-match ban from World Rugby.
Speaking on The Good, The Bad and The Rugby podcast, Horgan said Erasmus’s suggestion that the TMO may have ignored a series of knee-drop tackles by the French bordered on an accusation of match-fixing, PlanetRugby reported.
“He has called into question the integrity of officials. He has had the open question around match-fixing and he knows that those two things are never going to fly and never should fly, and it’s not the way to deal with some potentially legitimate issues he may have,” Horgan said.
“He’s fallen foul of that and I’m sure again if you speak to him and you read through the various social media sites, the conspiracy continues.”
Horgan drew a direct parallel between Erasmus and former US President Donald Trump. “It is depressing to say: ‘If we lose, it’s because something else has happened’. Trump would go into the election, ‘If I lose the election, it’s because it’s fixed’,” Horgan said.
“Then you see Bolsonaro in Brazil going, ‘my election was fixed as well’, and everybody goes their election is fixed. Therefore, if elections are fixed, why bother having elections? That’s the insidious nature of it.”
While acknowledging Erasmus as a “rugby genius” who has delivered two World Cups and a Lions series victory, Horgan argued the Springboks coach manufactures a “siege mentality” to motivate his team. “I think there is an element he’s always wanted to use this idea of them somehow being underdogs; how can the Springboks be underdogs with all they’ve achieved? But he does do that,” Horgan said.
“He creates that siege mentality and the problem is, where do you go to next and how do you create that position when you’re with a team that has such success and has done so well?”

Writing in The Irish Times, Horgan detailed how Erasmus’s “double-barrelled explosion of pure theatre” distracted from South Africa’s tactical errors and a virtuoso performance by France captain Antoine Dupont, who dismantled the Springboks’ defensive system close to the ruck.
Horgan noted France were decimated by injuries, forced to select two starting scrum-halves and losing hooker Julien Marchand during the warm-up, yet still exposed frailties in South Africa’s ruck defence and backfield coverage that Ireland will look to attack. They returned to their legendary attacking system from the 1970s, called “Le Petit General”, which places all their attacking organisation on their scrumhalf. Dupont delivered a virtuoso display for the ages.
Horgan also criticised Erasmus’s decision to start his “Bomb Squad” front-row replacements, a move “much of the rugby world considers to be against the spirit of our game,” which backfired as the Boks’ front-rowers wearing jerseys 16, 17 and 18 underperformed.
Erasmus grew up in Despatch in the Eastern Cape and won 36 caps for South Africa between 1997 and 2001, playing in the 1999 World Cup.
As a coach he led the Free State Cheetahs to their first Currie Cup title since 1976 in 2005, served as Munster’s director of rugby, and became the first SARU Director of Rugby in 2017 before guiding the Springboks to World Cup victories in 2019 and 2023, earning World Rugby Coach of the Year in 2019.
World Rugby’s six-match ban was described by Horgan as a light sentence. “Our referees need support, not public humiliation,” he wrote. Erasmus has the South African public convinced that defeat only comes because the rugby world is conspiring against them, a dynamic Horgan compared to Trump and his MAGA base.
“By the way, if they are, it’s the worst conspiracy theory of all time, them having won two World Cups and a Lions series,” Horgan said on the podcast.
More on Shane Horgan
South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus has been suspended for six international matches by World Rugby, starting with this Saturday's Nations Championship clash with Ireland at Aviva Stadium https://t.co/JpBqaao2nh
South Africa head coach Rassie Erasmus has been suspended for six international matches by World Rugby, starting with this Saturday's Nations Championship clash with Ireland at Aviva Stadiumhttps://t.co/K1QugjnASB