Utah’s First Community-Led Database for Missing, Murdered Indigenous Relatives Launches

Utah’s first community-led database for Missing and Murdered Indigenous Relatives launched Monday, shifting control of victims’ stories from police reports to the families who knew them.

  • Traces database launched Nov. 16 with 11 remembrances dating from 1985 to 2024
  • Native people are 1.5% of Utah’s population but over 5% of murder victims, per 2023 task force
  • Database built by MMIR Utah, Utah Investigative Journalism Project, and University of Utah
  • Families decide what information is public and whether law enforcement receives it

Families reclaim the narrative

Tammy Dee Platero, executive director and co-founder of MMIR Utah, said media coverage of MMIR cases typically stems from police investigations rather than families — and outlets sometimes use mugshots or criminal records to identify victims, which she says lowers public perception.

“Having people be able to control that narrative of what they want to share, I think that’s powerful in and of itself,” Platero told Utah News Dispatch. “That’s what we’re really trying to do — [share] stories owned and told by people.”

MMIR Utah staff operate the website and control what information is published. The entry system lets families designate what they want shared publicly and what assistance they need — from making calls to law enforcement to in-person support during court proceedings and ceremony, Native News Online reported.

Photo: amplifyutah.org

Disparity in the numbers

Despite making up 1.5% of Utah’s population, Native Americans and Alaska Natives account for over 5% of all murder victims statewide, according to the Utah Legislature’s 2023 MMIR Task Force Report. A 2021 KUTV investigation found law enforcement and criminal justice officials in Utah admit they don’t know exactly how many MMIR cases exist in the state. Nationally, the FBI received 10,248 reports of missing Indigenous people in 2024, Native News Online reported.

Of the 6,000 Indigenous women who went missing nationwide from 2016 through 2022, the Department of Justice’s missing persons database showed only 116 such cases, according to a 2022 KSL article cited by Utah News Dispatch.

Traces: Telling the Stories of Utah’s Missing and Murdered Indigenous People — KSL News Utah

First entries honor the forgotten

The database includes 11 posted remembrances. Cornell Burns, murdered Jan. 20, 1990 in Salt Lake City at age 23, “loved to dance, was a great cook and took good care of his mother,” according to his entry. Police collected bloodstained shoes as possible evidence but later disposed of them, making DNA testing impossible, police records show.

Rebecca Jane White went missing from South Salt Lake in 2012 and may have been experiencing homelessness; her entry notes she may have used the last names Fasthorse or Runninghorse. Ermalinda Garza Sherman, 32, was found April 2, 1991 on a desert road south of St. George with gunshot wounds and blunt force trauma; her killing remains unsolved, KSL reported.

Matthew Jay Broncho, an enrolled member of the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes, went missing from Idaho in 2019; his remains were found five years later in the Hansel Mountains in Box Elder County, though his case remains unresolved.

A sign at the entry to the Arizona portion of the Navajo Nation off U.S. 160 at the New Mexico border, photographed April 4
Photo: ksl.com

Building toward community ownership

Eric Peterson, founder and senior reporter of the Utah Investigative Journalism Project, spent 18 months collecting public records, police reports and existing media coverage to build the initial entries. “Honestly, there would be no greater success for this project than to have all our reporting and writing replaced entirely by the shared memories and stories of friends, loved ones,” he told KSL.

Funding came from a University of Utah Department of Communication seed grant. Department chair Avery Holton said “a flagship university should be serving the state and should be serving its communities.” Ozzy Escarate, director of Utah’s Office of American Indian and Alaska Native Health and Family Services, called the database “hugely impactful because it’ll put [Native communities] in the forefront, and that’s been the missing piece.”

Platero seeks $120,000 to sustain Traces through 2027

Platero aims to raise $120,000 to keep Traces running through 2027, promote the database in Native communities, and present to Utah tribal leaders. She hopes to eventually hire a website developer and traveling storyteller to meet families in their communities.

“These names … if they’re lucky, may be on the news for a day,” Platero said. “This is a part of remembering their stories, and we’re hoping to get more families to contribute, and feel like they have a place here — like they’re not just forgotten about.”