The fight for Senate majority leader has turned on Israel, dividing Maryland’s delegation and the Democratic caucus weeks before the Dec. 1 vote.
Chris Van Hollen, challenging Chuck Schumer for the top post, has made the U.S.-Israel relationship the sharpest policy contrast between them. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in the United States, told CNN he has the votes to win. Van Hollen argues the midterm results demand new leadership on affordability, the Iran war and accountability for the Trump administration.
A decade of divergence
When Van Hollen first ran for Senate in 2016, pro-Israel donors backed him over Donna Edwards. Haim Saban gave $100,000 to his campaign, and J Street recommended both candidates, CNN reported. Van Hollen then called the U.S.-Israel bond “unbreakable” and said Israel should respond to attacks “as it deems best.”
“It should respond as it deems best, as Israel deems best,” he said. “I would not try and interfere or undermine in any way the decisions of the state of Israel to defend itself.” “I understand the impulses that are driving Israel’s actions,” he wrote to then-U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, “but I strongly believe that a continuation of the bombing campaign as it is being carried out is against the interests of [Israel] and the United States.”
In the Senate, he opposed Ben Cardin’s efforts to block boycotts of Israeli companies. The gap widened after Oct. 7, 2023. Van Hollen boycotted Netanyahu’s 2024 address to Congress; Cardin, who is Jewish, greeted the prime minister as a friend.
I welcome any discussion about the future of our caucus and the important work ahead. I’m proud of what we’ve accomplished together—55 seats and counting is an amazing result—and I have the votes to continue serving as Democratic Leader. I look forward to leading our new…
The current fault line
Van Hollen now calls for conditioning military aid, accuses Israel of genocide in Gaza — a charge Israel denies, Newsweek noted — and led 12 senators urging leaders to strip expanded defense cooperation from the FY2027 defense bill. He has attacked AIPAC’s role in primaries, alleging Schumer sided with the group and crypto interests against candidates who later won, including Abdul El-Sayed in Michigan and Troy Jackson in Maine.
“While his views have remained consistent, the facts on the ground have not,” spokesperson Francesca Amodeo said in a statement to CNN. “The Israeli government has become increasingly hard-line in its approach, diminishing the possibility of a two-state solution, including through its indiscriminate attacks on Gaza and its complicity in the escalating violence in the West Bank.”

Van Hollen has backed resolutions to block arms sales to Israel. “My position is that American taxpayers should not be providing a blank check to the government of Israel or any government, regardless of their conduct,” he said on Fox News.
I used to go door-to-door with him. He did not portray any element of what he’s become. I’ve become so thoroughly disgusted with him.”
Maryland mirrors the split
Van Hollen responded: “Senator Alsobrooks and I will continue to respect one another and work together on behalf of Marylanders every day.”
Edwards, who once ran against Van Hollen, endorsed him Tuesday. “Like many legislators, Chris has had a bit of an evolution in his thinking around the US-Israel relationship, and I think that’s a positive development,” she told CNN.
Schumer silent as Van Hollen challenges leadership precedent
The last contested Senate Democratic leadership race was in 1994. Schumer’s office declined comment to CNN. Van Hollen told MS NOW his bid is “much bigger than that.” The caucus votes Dec. 1.
More on Israel
Chris Van Hollen says he has the votes to block a fast-track attempt to cement Chuck Schumer atop Dems’ incoming Senate majority — and a warning that some colleagues fear retaliation for opposing the NY senator.👇 More from @playbookdc: https://t.co/CVQM5j45g8 pic.twitter.com/dGMx9jHPhm