Vaughn: Letter Alone Does Not Establish Criminal Responsibility for Gusciora

An anonymous letter mailed from Philadelphia landed in former Councilwoman Robin Vaughn’s hands days after Mayor Reed Gusciora was forced into a runoff, accusing him of abusing a 14-year-old at a Princeton address where public records show he did not live and a house that had not yet been built.

The Jersey Vindicator reviewed property records and campaign filings that place Gusciora at 166 Nassau Street in 1998, four years before he purchased the MacLean Street home referenced in the letter. The house at 20 MacLean Street was constructed in 2001 as part of the Kathleen Edwards Houses development, and Gusciora’s deed was recorded on August 26, 2002.

“The letter is absurd, but the damage has been done because now it’s reverberated around Facebook and keeps popping up,” Gusciora told The Jersey Vindicator on Friday, confirming he had retained counsel.

The allegations surfaced two weeks before the December 8 runoff between Gusciora and police detective Corey McNair, who led the November 3 general election with roughly 37 percent of the vote to the incumbent’s 23 percent.

Vaughn posted the five-page letter to Facebook at 1:53 p.m. on Monday, November 16, writing that she had received it from a man identifying himself as “John Doe” and had forwarded it to the Mercer County Prosecutor’s Office and the state Attorney General’s Office.

She acknowledged the claims were unverified. “The letter alone does not establish accuracy, any person’s identity, or criminal responsibility,” she wrote. The post was shared 54 times before it was removed later that week. Vaughn did not respond to questions from The Jersey Vindicator.

The view of bay street crossroad the street in nassau the capital of the bahamas

The letter’s author, who claims to be an Army sergeant major recently returned from South Korea, describes four Saturday encounters in August 1998 at 20 MacLean Street, including details of a backyard, an electric mower, and a housemate. Property records and a former neighbor contradict the physical layout.

Kevin Wilkes, an architect and former Princeton councilman who lived at 16 MacLean Street from 2005 to 2010, told The Jersey Vindicator the development never had backyards — only a paved parking lot behind the units. “In my five years living two doors away from Reed, the only people I saw him bring in and out were his mom and his sister, Holly,” Wilkes said.

Gusciora’s 1998 address on Nassau Street was a studio apartment surrounded by pavement, with no yard. Federal Election Commission filings from May 30, 2000 list him at 166 Nassau Street for a congressional campaign.

The envelope bearing the letter was postmarked Philadelphia on November 7, four days after the general election. Metadata on the scanned copy Vaughn shared shows the letter was scanned on November 10, six days before she posted it. The return address on the envelope is Vaughn’s own.

Jersey councilwoman robin vaughn

The letter also contains a claim that South Korea executes drug dealers with lethal doses of heroin. South Korea has not carried out an execution since 1997.

Vaughn and Gusciora have a documented history. In May 2020, during a conference call, Vaughn called Gusciora a “pedophile” and a “big fat idiot, f—ing drug addict,” according to audio released by the mayor’s office. She also suggested he brought “young boys” into City Hall.

Lieutenant Governor Sheila Oliver, Garden State Equality, the LGBTQ Victory Fund, and the state Democratic chairman called for her resignation. The council voted 5-2 against censure. Vaughn later apologized for her language but remained in office until 2022, when she challenged Gusciora for mayor and finished third.

On the trail this week, Gusciora said a resident showed him the letter and he was “ambushed by men who were waving it in my face.” McNair, meanwhile, posted a video of Gusciora in a blonde wig and white dress, captioned “racist queen,” after a video of McNair in a chicken suit circulated earlier. McNair has declined interviews and refused to debate Gusciora since the November 3 election.

“We should be discussing the issues,” Gusciora said Friday. “It’s unfortunate.”