A new commentary from the Jewish Federation of Greater Portland uses the Torah portion Vayetzei to frame biblical mandrakes as history’s first documented foraging expedition and a sophisticated narrative about infertility, agency, and divine negotiation.
The analysis, published this week by jewishportland.org, centers on Genesis 30, where Reuven, the eldest son of Jacob and Leah, brings mandrakes to his mother during the wheat harvest. Medieval commentator Rashi notes the text specifies the harvest season to prove Reuven stole nothing cultivated, gathering only ownerless plants — a definition of foraging that resonates deeply in the Pacific Northwest.
The botany of desperation
In the ancient world, mandrakes were prized as both aphrodisiac and fertility medicine. Leah had stopped bearing children after four sons; Reuven’s gift was an attempt to restart her fertility. The gesture carries a particular tenderness: the nineteenth-century commentator Malbim reads it as a child placing his mother’s longing for more children above a typical sibling’s jealousy.
The mandrakes quickly become currency in a complex domestic economy. Rachel, Jacob’s other wife and years into her own infertility, begs Leah for the plants. She has already tried surrogacy via her handmaiden Bilhah, a move echoing her grandmother-in-law Sarah’s use of Hagar.
But the commentary draws a sharp distinction: Abraham had no heir; Jacob already had four sons. Rachel’s surrogacy was for her own sake, not her husband’s lineage. When Bilhah bears a son, Rachel claims him immediately — “God has heeded my plea and given me a son,” she says, naming him Dan.
When the medicine fails
The mandrakes do not work for Rachel. Leah conceives three more children instead. Only later does the text report: “God remembered Rachel; God heeded her and opened her womb. She conceived and bore a son… and she named him Joseph.”
“The mandrakes do not cure Rachel’s barrenness, but they do alert God to her desperation and the lengths to which she will go in order to conceive.”
Rachel Havrelock, professor of English, University of Illinois at Chicago, contributor to The Torah: A Women’s Commentary (2007)
Rabbi David Kimchi, a medieval authority, uses the failure as proof the plant has no medical efficacy. Havrelock offers a different reading: Rachel’s three-part protest — articulation of discontent, surrogacy, medicinal aid — is met by a three-part divine response: “God remembered… listened… and opened her womb” (Gen. 30:22). The foraging, the bargaining, the surrogacy — all become forms of prayer, ways of insisting that the covenantal future include her.

A Portland lens on ancient text
The Federation’s decision to highlight the foraging angle speaks to a region where wild food gathering is both cultural practice and ecological ethic. Rashi’s insistence that Reuven took “only ownerless things about which no one is particular” lands differently in a city with active urban foraging maps and public fruit-tree inventories. The commentary does not flatten the ancient text into modern environmentalism; it lets the two speak to each other.
Havrelock, associate professor of Jewish Studies and English at the University of Illinois at Chicago, authored River Jordan: The Mythology of a Dividing Line, which combines biblical studies, literary and political theory, and the politics of interpretation. Her co-authored book Women on the Biblical Road began her work on gender and the Bible, and she contributed to The Torah: A Women’s Commentary in 2007.
What remains open is whether the text ultimately validates human effort or subordinates it to divine timing. The mandrakes fail as medicine but succeed as signal. Rachel’s son Joseph becomes the linchpin of the family’s survival in Egypt. The foraging expedition, dismissed by Kimchi as superstition, becomes in Havrelock’s reading the catalyst that moves heaven.