Intolerance of Uncertainty Rise Accelerated After 2012, Study Finds

Intolerance of uncertainty among college students in the United States and Canada rose three times faster after 2012 than in the two decades before, a meta-analysis published November 18 in JAMA Psychiatry found.

The study, led by researchers at Columbia University Mailman School of Public Health and Boston University School of Public Health, analyzed 138 peer-reviewed studies encompassing 35,296 undergraduates who completed the Intolerance of Uncertainty Scale between 1992 and 2023. Average scores climbed roughly 0.65 points per year across the full span, but the acceleration around 2012 was sharp and sustained.

Our results provide updated insights into one of the core building blocks of anxiety: intolerance of uncertainty.

Katherine M. Keyes, professor of Epidemiology, Columbia Mailman School of Public Health, senior author

Keyes emphasized that intolerance of uncertainty (IU) is not a disease itself but “an intermediary cognitive process that contributes to the development of anxiety”. People with higher IU tend to need predictable outcomes before engaging in everyday activities — attending class, showing up at a social gathering — and become distressed when they cannot forecast what will happen.

Intolerance of uncertainty
Photo: Boston University

Scores Triple After 2012

The data show a clear break. From 1992 to 2011, IU scores rose at a modest, steady pace. From 2012 to 2023, the rate of increase tripled. The authors screened 799 abstracts and 294 full texts via Web of Science, ultimately merging 92 eligible articles with a prior meta-analysis that covered data through 2014. The combined dataset allowed a fixed-effect meta-regression weighted by sample size and adjusted for age and sex or gender distribution.

Any explanation will be strongest if it accounts for both the long-term upward trend since the 1990s and the inflection point observed around 2012.

Jeroen M. van Baar, postdoctoral associate, Department of Epidemiology, Boston University School of Public Health, first author

Van Baar and colleagues point to a cluster of societal shifts that accelerated around the same time: widespread smartphone adoption, the rise of algorithmic social media, mounting academic pressure, growing loneliness, economic instability, childhood adversity, and later the COVID-19 pandemic. “It is likely that these factors are intertwined and mutually reinforcing, jointly contributing to population-level increases in intolerance of uncertainty and anxiety among young adults,” van Baar said.

Awareness Cannot Explain the Rise

Researchers have debated whether rising anxiety rates reflect genuine distress or simply greater mental-health literacy — young people recognizing and labeling symptoms they might once have ignored. The study offers a counterpoint. Because intolerance of uncertainty remains “a relatively unfamiliar concept outside psychology,” van Baar said, it is less susceptible to reporting bias driven by awareness.

The Hidden Trait That May Explain Rising Anxiety in Young Adults — HealthDay

“The fact that we observed a consistent increase in intolerance of uncertainty that mirrored trends in anxiety and mood disorder symptoms suggests these patterns are unlikely to be explained solely by greater mental health awareness and may instead reflect genuine changes in underlying mental health,” Keyes said.

Treatments Already Target Intolerance

The authors highlight that evidence-based treatments targeting IU — primarily cognitive-behavioral protocols developed for anxiety and mood disorders — have demonstrated efficacy. “The encouraging news is that effective interventions to reduce IU already exist for people with anxiety and mood disorders,” Keyes said. “The persistent increase in intolerance of uncertainty justifies continued research into the role of uncertainty in the epidemiology of anxiety and the development of interventions that effectively reduce IU.”

Intolerance of Uncertainty Rise Accelerated After 2012, Study Finds
Photo: News Medical

Katherine M. Keyes graduated from the University of Minnesota in 2001 with degrees in theatre arts and business before earning her PhD at Columbia. Early in her career she led a cross-national review showing that cohorts born after World War II were more likely to binge drink, and later documented the “Great Sleep Recession” among U.S. adolescents.

During the pandemic she was senior author on a study that found daily social media use alone did not raise depression risk in teens, emphasizing the importance of social context.

The study was supported by the National Institute of Mental Health (grant 5T32MH013043). Co-authors include Ava Aimable (Columbia Mailman), Taylor Teckchandani and R. Nicholas Carleton (University of Regina), Marcia Pescador Jimenez, and Ray Y. Hong (National University of Singapore).