- Independent audit by CliftonLarsonAllen rates state progress “unsatisfactory”
- Project cost estimate rises from $70 million to $80 million
- State plans 24 weeks of remediation before proposing restart timeline
- Legislature has approved $25 million; $17 million spent through October
The review, commissioned by State Auditor Doug Hoffer and conducted by CliftonLarsonAllen, found that crucial questions about which functions Workday can replace and how it will interact with five existing state systems “remain unanswered,” auditors said.
The project seeks to replace human resources, finance, budgeting, labor and transportation software with the Workday platform. “How can you help us, like, not be freaking out about this?” Rep. Monique Priestley, D-Bradford, asked state officials at a Joint Information Technology Oversight Committee meeting Friday. “It just feels like we’re — we’re doing this over and over again.”
Sen. Rob Plunkett, D-Bennington, who chairs the committee, called the findings “shocking.”
Lisa Gauvin, an IT consultant for the Legislative Joint Fiscal Office, told lawmakers 18 months ago that the Agency of Digital Services had not done sufficient analysis to determine which functions Workday could replace, Vermont Digger reported. Then-Digital Services Secretary Denise Reilly-Hughes disagreed at the time, saying her team had done multiple “gap analyses” to confirm the system’s ability to fill the state’s needs. Reilly-Hughes left her role in mid-October to take a job at Microsoft. Jim Kreiser, a principal at CliftonLarsonAllen, said projects like this generally take states between two and four years to complete.
That makes Vermont, already about six years into its modernization effort according to Gauvin, something of an “outlier.” “You may be at an inflection point of deciding: Have we even made the right decision?” he said. Sean Brown, the state’s deputy secretary of administration, said his team largely agreed with many of the audit’s findings. Several areas carry “substantial risk” currently. Officials will spend 24 weeks addressing the audit’s concerns and preparing to implement the new system, then return with a proposed timeline to restart the project.
Rhode Island and Oregon have also experienced difficulties implementing Workday. The Legislature has approved roughly $25 million so far, of which the state had spent about $17 million at the end of October, according to Chrissy Gilhuly, a spokesperson for the Agency of Administration.
“Every time there’s a delay in this project, that’s another cost,” Gauvin said at Friday’s meeting. “From my perspective, we’re past the point of assurances,” Priestley said over text Friday. “The bar is high for a reason.”
Rep. Monique Priestley, D-Bradford, said over text Friday that she would need a detailed plan showing how Workday would replace particular functions before supporting more funding. She added that the bar is high for a reason and that lawmakers are past the point of assurances.
That makes Vermont, already about six years into its modernization effort according to Gauvin, something of an outlier. “You may be at an inflection point of deciding: Have we even made the right decision?” he said.