Virgil Thew, 49, pleaded guilty Monday to three counts of first-degree intentional homicide for the December 2024 killings of his girlfriend and two girls in New Lisbon, Juneau County prosecutors confirmed.
The plea covers the deaths of Elizabeth Kolba, 33, and two girls — 12-year-old Alexandria Taylor and 13-year-old Skyla Sorenson — found shot in the head inside a deadbolted bedroom at his mother’s apartment on December 30, 2024. Thew had initially told deputies he was on a “21-day survival challenge” when they found him in a stolen vehicle near Elroy ten days later, according to the criminal complaint cited by CBS Minnesota.
Victims Found Shot in Locked Bedroom
Kolba was Thew’s live-in girlfriend. Alexandria was Thew’s stepdaughter while Skyla was Alexandria’s cousin, a probable cause arrest affidavit obtained by Law&Crime said. All three were discovered in a bed, covered by blankets, in the locked bedroom of the apartment on West Bridge Street. Each had suffered close-range gunshot wounds to the head.
Skyla’s father, Jerry Sorenson, called police for a welfare check after her phone’s Snapchat location placed her at the residence, Law&Crime reported. Officers first saw no sign of the victims. Later that day, relatives at the home found the bodies. Thew’s relatives told investigators he was the only person with keys to the bedroom.
Jerry Sorenson told local CBS affiliate WKBT, “Will you be a man and tell somebody ‘Why?’ Please,” as reported by Law&Crime.
Suspect Arrested in Stolen Vehicle, Confesses to Killings
Deputies located Thew on January 9, 2025, sleeping in a stolen vehicle about twelve miles southwest of New Lisbon in Elroy, WQOW reported. He gave a false name at first, then admitted his identity.
During an interview with detectives, Thew recalled shooting the three victims and directed authorities to the hidden weapon, which was recovered, according to the affidavit cited by Law&Crime. He said he had traveled through wooded areas to avoid capture before stealing the vehicle.

Thew was previously convicted of burglary in 1999, CBS Minnesota noted. Charges of felon in possession of a firearm, taking a vehicle without consent, resisting an officer and three counts of hiding a corpse were dismissed but read in at the plea hearing, WQOW said.
New Lisbon, the Juneau County city where the killings occurred, originated as a Ho-Chunk winter encampment called Waac Hot’ųp Ra, meaning “where canoes are placed.” The United States acquired the land in an 1836 treaty, and the first white settlers arrived in 1838 to harvest lumber, building a sawmill and log boom on the Lemonweir River.
The community, first named Mill Haven, was renamed New Lisbon and incorporated in March 1870 after the La Crosse and Milwaukee Railroad reached it in 1857. The 2020 census recorded a population of 1,748, which included 210 people incarcerated at the New Lisbon Correctional Institution.
Sentencing ahead
Thew is scheduled to be sentenced on December 4.
Related reading
- Wilmington Startup Boots & Ladders Productizes Local Services to Address Trades Shortage
- Bridgeport Community Rallies Around Soto Family After Fatal Harral Avenue Fire Displaces 27
- Kinale Girls Wins East African Rugby Title, Supplied Nine Players to Kenya Youth Olympic Gold Squad (world-today-news.com)