Washington Supreme Court Unanimously Rejects Recall of Pacific County Commissioner Lisa Olsen

The Washington Supreme Court unanimously shut down a recall effort against Pacific County Commissioner Lisa Olsen on December 4, ruling the petition failed to prove she intended to break the law.

The decision keeps Olsen, a Bay Center Republican first elected in 2016, on the Board of County Commissioners through her term ending in 2028. It also sharpens the legal standard for recall campaigns statewide, requiring petitioners to produce direct evidence of a public official’s intent to violate the Open Public Meetings Act — not just evidence that a violation occurred.

Raymond resident Irving Edersheim and the group Recall Rangers of Pacific County filed the petition last March 24, alleging Olsen participated in five executive sessions during 2024 without an attorney present, a requirement under RCW 42.30.110 for discussing potential litigation. The petition also accused her of holding a secret meeting before the board’s unanimous December 26, 2024 vote to remove the county jail from the Sheriff’s Office purview.

Writing for the court, the justices said the recall charges were “factually and legally insufficient” because the petitioners could not pinpoint when actual violations took place or show Olsen acted with intent.

“In the recall process, courts act as gatekeepers, and our role is ‘to ensure that the recall process is not used to harass public officials by subjecting them to frivolous or unsubstantiated charges.’”

Washington State Supreme Court, unanimous opinion, Dec. 4

The court said that meeting minutes for the October 8 and October 22 sessions showed legal counsel was present. For the June 11, June 25, and October 31 sessions where no attorney attended, the justices ruled that mere attendance without counsel does not constitute malfeasance or a violation of the oath of office absent proof of intent.

On the second charge, the court found the petition failed to identify the date, location, or nature of any alleged private meeting about the jail decision, calling the allegation too vague to proceed.

RRPC Secretary Amber Jacobs framed the ruling as a retreat for accountability. In a statement December 5, she said the court acknowledged Olsen “knowingly violated the law” but ruled that knowledge alone is not enough.

The court ruled that Olsen’s knowing violation of law was not enough, and that direct evidence of her intent to knowingly violate the law is required for the recall to proceed. The court also said that the allegations lack the specificity required.

The Pepper case allowed a recall to proceed based on a council member’s knowing violation of the OPMA without a separate showing of specific intent to break the law. The Olsen ruling effectively overrules that precedent by demanding direct evidence of intent.

Olsen’s legal defense was paid with county funds after Prosecutor Michael Rothman determined the recall regarded her official duties. Public records obtained by the Chinook Observer show the tab reached $118,007.20 through November 30, 2025, including a $5,000 fund applied to the total.

19th District Representative Jim Walsh (R-Aberdeen) called the outcome predictable. “Another example of how and why recalls in Washington are difficult to complete successfully,” he posted December 4. “Courts rule on whether a recall makes a strong enough case before it can proceed to gather signatures and get on the ballot. They rarely rule that a recall does that, so most recall efforts like this one die in court.”

The ruling leaves the Recall Rangers with no path to the ballot. Olsen remains in office. The court has not yet indicated whether it will publish a formal opinion expanding on the intent standard for future cases.