West Virginia Sues New Jersey Over Solar Credits, Alleging Commerce Clause Violations

West Virginia filed a federal lawsuit Wednesday in New Jersey against the state and its energy regulators, claiming New Jersey’s Solar Renewable Energy Credit programs illegally block out-of-state solar generators and inflate costs for ratepayers across the 13-state PJM Interconnection grid.

The suit alleges the geographic restrictions violate the Constitution’s Commerce Clause by channeling solar investment and jobs to New Jersey at the expense of out-of-state competitors. “The geographic restrictions serve a purely economic purpose: channeling solar investment and jobs to New Jersey at the expense of out-of-state competitors,” West Virginia states in its lawsuit. “That is precisely the kind of economic protectionism the Commerce Clause forbids.”

West Virginia Sues New Jersey Over Solar Credits, Alleging Commerce Clause Violations
Photo: yahoo.com

Power producers on PJM’s grid earn credits for each megawatt of renewable energy they generate, which can be sold separately from the electricity and used by fossil fuel plants to meet renewable benchmarks under programs like the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative.

While New Jersey allows out-of-state generators to obtain credits for wind, tidal, methane and other generation types, its solar credit rules require plants to be physically tied into New Jersey’s energy infrastructure, the suit alleges.

This exclusion makes New Jersey’s solar installations artificially profitable, forcing West Virginia’s solar generators to sell power on voluntary markets where prices range from about $2 to $8 per megawatt hour, compared to $88.94 to $105.74 through New Jersey’s solar credits. West Virginia argues the exclusions have already cost its producers between $20 million and $22 million in missed credits and could cost them as much as $296 million between 2027 and 2031.

“We should all be working toward a more efficient and reliable system, but rules like these stand in the way of progress, and ultimately all households and businesses pay the price,” West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey said in a statement. He said New Jersey’s rules have raised electricity prices for West Virginia ratepayers because the state’s utilities would have passed savings from the credits onto their consumers.

The lawsuit also claims New Jersey has failed to meet its own annual solar procurement goals. Though the state targets 300 megawatts of new solar annually, it met that goal only once between 2022 and 2025.

Spokespeople for Gov. Mikie Sherrill, who has made energy affordability a key focus during her campaign and first 10 months in office, declined to comment on pending litigation. Michael Symons, a spokesperson for Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, indicated New Jersey would defend the programs.

“We will continue to work with Governor Sherrill and her administration to support the development of renewable energy and drive costs down for our state’s residents,” he said. “We look forward to defending against this lawsuit in court.”