Yankees Agree to Two-Year, $18M Deal With Loaisiga, 2029 Option

The Yankees were supposed to be out on Jonathan Loaisiga.

By Thursday night they had agreed to a two-year, $18 million contract with a club option for 2029, bringing the right-hander back to the Bronx after a single season in Arizona.

Nicaraguan reporter Levi Luna broke the agreement first. MLB.com’s Mark Feinsand confirmed the financial terms, and ESPN’s Jorge Castillo added the option year. The deal returns a pitcher who spent his first eight seasons in New York but appeared only 50 times from 2023 through 2025 before a minor-league flier with the Diamondbacks revived his market.

“I was interested in a reunion with Arizona but would see how free agency unfolded,” Loaisiga told Arizona Sports after the season. The Diamondbacks' young back-end trio of Justin Martinez, Brandyn Garcia and Juan Morillo left general manager Mike Hazen reluctant to spend big on a reliever, and a strong market that included the Mets, Dodgers, Blue Jays and Phillies ultimately priced Arizona out.

The Bronx payroll math

With Loaisiga’s $9 million average annual value, the Yankees have now committed roughly $34.4 million to relief pitching this offseason. Earlier in the week they re-signed Tim Hill to a one-year, $2.25 million deal, and David Bednar accepted a $23.15 million qualifying offer on Tuesday. The total pushes New York’s payroll back toward the $300 million threshold owner Hal Steinbrenner has resisted crossing.

Move Term Annual Value
David Bednar Qualifying offer $23.15 million
Jonathan Loaisiga 2 years + option $9 million AAV
Tim Hill 1 year $2.25 million

Steinbrenner’s ceiling and a potential salary cap make further high-priced bullpen additions unlikely. The Yankees are now more likely to pursue trade targets such as Luis Medina or Anthony Bender for depth rather than chase another free-agent arm.

What the 2026 season proved

Loaisiga made 67 appearances — a career high — and posted a 2.42 ERA with a 1.03 WHIP. He induced ground balls at a 56 percent rate and limited walks, working efficiently behind Arizona’s defense. The workload answered the durability questions that followed him out of New York, but the injury history remains the primary risk factor in the Bronx’s calculation.

Yankees Agree to Two-Year, $18M Deal With Loaisiga, 2029 Option
Photo: si.com

Paul Blackburn, another breakout reliever for the Yankees in 2026, is now expected to sign elsewhere. Jon Heyman noted New York beat out the Mets for Loaisiga, a development that likely ends Blackburn’s tenure. A contract similar to Loaisiga’s — roughly $20 million over two years with an option — would push the payroll past Steinbrenner’s comfort zone.

The New York Yankees were founded in 1903 when Frank Farrell and Bill Devery purchased the defunct Baltimore Orioles franchise and established the New York Highlanders, who were renamed the Yankees in 1913. The team has won 27 World Series championships, a Major League Baseball record, and 41 American League pennants. Owned by the Steinbrenner family since 1973, the franchise is valued at $8.2 billion as of 2025, making it the most valuable in MLB.

The catching question remains

With the bullpen absorbing over $30 million, the Yankees’ next free-agent move is expected to address the catching room. Carson Kelly is available at what SI.com described as a presumably reasonable price. Whether New York can fit him under the self-imposed cap while still acquiring a fallback reliever via trade will define the rest of the offseason.