Zelenskyy: U.S. Asked Ukraine to Trade Donbas Withdrawal for NATO Membership

U.S. negotiators asked Ukraine for the first time whether it would withdraw troops from the parts of Donbas it still controls in exchange for NATO membership, President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said Friday after trilateral talks in Abu Dhabi.

The proposal marks a sharp turn from President Donald Trump’s position just months earlier.

In an August 2025 interview with Fox News, Trump ruled out Kyiv’s entry into the alliance, saying, “They’re not going to be a part of NATO.” Now, his envoys — son-in-law Jared Kushner and Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff — have floated a trade-off that would give Russia territory while offering Ukraine the collective defense guarantee Moscow has long treated as a casus belli.

Zelenskyy rejected the linkage outright. “If Putin expects Ukraine’s neutrality to be enshrined, that’s not going to happen,” he said. Any arrangement would not involve recognizing occupied territories as Russian.

He also warned that broader discussions about a new European security framework could let Putin seek changes to NATO’s military presence, including the withdrawal of American troops from the Baltics. “I think Putin will bring up Finland and Sweden. I’m sure he will raise the issue of Hungary and the presence of American troops in the Baltic countries,” Zelenskyy said.

Abu Dhabi talks yield POW deal, no ceasefire

The two-day session in Abu Dhabi this week marked the first direct talks between Ukrainian and Russian delegations in months. Mediated by Kushner and Witkoff, the meetings ended without a breakthrough on a ceasefire. Negotiators agreed to exchange more than 1,000 prisoners of war on each side — Zelenskyy estimated 1,200 to 1,300. The Russian delegation said it had no mandate to decide on the NATO-for-territory question, a response Zelenskyy described as “unwilling.”

Zelenskyy questions U.S. definition of security guarantees

Zelenskyy pressed U.S. officials to clarify what “something like NATO” entails. He said American negotiators replied they had “something like NATO” in mind when asked whether the proposed deal included Article 5-style collective defense. “I’m not sure we have a common acceptance of Article 5,” Zelenskyy said Thursday after a Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin. “What does it mean?”

Europe divided, Russia maximalist

French President Emmanuel Macron said Thursday it was time to revisit “the question of Ukraine’s NATO accession” in light of Russia’s “maximalist” demands. German hosts of the Berlin meeting, by contrast, did not want to pursue the topic, participants told the Wall Street Journal.

Zelensky Slams US Peace Push 'They Want Ukraine To Give Up Donbas' — Times Now World

NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte declined to comment on the territory-for-membership proposal at a November 17 Ukraine Defense Contact Group session in Brussels, praising Kushner and Witkoff as central to Washington’s peace effort while drawing “a clear line around the limits of my public commentary.”

A document circulated by the Russian side demands removal of the NATO-aspiration clause from Ukraine’s constitution, a pledge that the alliance not deploy troops or equipment in Ukraine, a halt to Western arms supplies, and the withdrawal from Europe and the Caucasus of missiles capable of reaching Russian territory. European participants viewed the demands as maximalist opening positions rather than a final settlement plan.

Zelensky Says US Raised Territory-for-NATO Trade-Off
Photo: Newsweek

Majority rejects troop withdrawal from Donbas

A Kyiv International Institute of Sociology survey conducted October 8–16 found 61% of respondents categorically reject withdrawing troops from Ukrainian-held parts of Donbas — including cities such as Kramatorsk and Sloviansk — even in exchange for U.S. and European security guarantees.

Another 35% said they would begrudgingly accept such a deal. Zelenskyy said that committing to neutrality would require a constitutional amendment, and any territorial concession would need explicit confirmation from Washington and NATO partners before a referendum could be held.

Zelenskyy came to the presidency from a career in entertainment. He co-founded the production company Kvartal 95 and starred in the television series Servant of the People, playing a fictional Ukrainian president from 2015 to 2019.

A political party bearing the show’s name was founded in March 2018, and he won the 2019 election with 73.23 percent of the vote in the second round, the largest landslide in Ukrainian presidential history. His party then secured a parliamentary majority in the subsequent snap election.

Next diplomatic test: November 26–27 European Council summit

The European Commission is preparing its 22nd sanctions package against Russia and a financing proposal for Ukraine ahead of the November 26–27 European Council summit. Zelenskyy said a four-way meeting — Ukraine, Europe, America and Russia — should now take place to agree on the agenda for the next quadrilateral round.

Whether Trump has actually reversed his 2025 opposition to Ukrainian membership remains unclear; the Wall Street Journal noted it is uncertain how seriously U.S. mediators are considering accession and whether Trump has changed his position.