In a column for Tallahassee Reports, Mary Ann Lindley argues that a 1994 opinion piece she wrote for the Tallahassee Democrat reads like a script for the current fight over City Manager Karen Jumonville.
The 1994 column, published March 8, described a new City Commission majority moving to oust longtime City Manager Dan Kleman. Lindley writes that the parallels to today are striking: a newly elected progressive majority is now pushing to remove City Manager Karen Jumonville.
Lindley’s column named three commissioners driving the effort then — Ron Weaver, Penny Herman and Scott Maddox. Weaver, helped into office by the police union, claimed a mandate to fire Kleman despite promising voters he would take time to learn the job.
Herman, Lindley wrote, wanted a return to patronage politics where commissioners control hiring and firing. Maddox, she noted, professed respect for Kleman but appeared to be following his father’s wishes; Charles Maddox was state president of the Police Benevolent Association.
“It’s risky business for a commission to act so precipitously on a matter so vital to the long-term interests of the community.”
Frank P. Sherwood, FSU’s eminent scholar in public administration, told Lindley at the time. Sherwood pointed to Kleman’s selflessness during consolidation efforts and said that some city charters impose a six-month cooling-off period preventing a new commission from immediately firing a manager.
Lindley writes that Mayor Jeremy Matlow has expressed similar sentiments about Jumonville and cited a mandate from voters to justify the new majority’s direction. Questions have also surfaced about whether the new majority intends to replace other senior staff, reviving the personnel-interference concern Lindley raised three decades ago.
The 1994 commission ultimately retained Kleman. Lindley’s column closed with Sherwood’s warning that a cooling-off period might save new commissioners from “plummeting headlong into folly” and protect voters who elect officials making big decisions for little reasons.