70 VT Households Helped After State Missed 1,700 From FEMA Data, VTDigger

Vermont flood survivors waited ten months while the state relied on a hotline list that missed 1,700 households, a VTDigger investigation found.

Case managers ultimately secured about $673,000 in federal and philanthropic aid for 70 households after cross-referencing FEMA data in November 2025, The Cool Down reported. More than 2,000 households had applied to FEMA after the 2024 floods, yet for 10 months in 2025 recovery officials worked only from damage reports submitted through Vermont’s 2-1-1 hotline, leaving a federal list of survivors unused, according to VTDigger.

She said no state case manager contacted her.

The gap mirrors the 2023 response. After the 2023 floods, the FEMA-funded case management program took eight months to begin helping survivors and opened 404 cases while more than 6,000 households applied for aid, according to VTDigger. Liz Scharf, who helped oversee Capstone Community Action’s case management work, confirmed the timeline to The Cool Down.

A suburban house surrounded by floodwaters after heavy rain, showing impact of natural disaster
Photo: vermontpost.com

The hotline blind spot

For 10 months in 2025, the state’s recovery office built its outreach around the 2-1-1 hotline. When officials finally turned to FEMA’s records in November, they identified about 1,700 households that never appeared on the hotline list, VTDigger reported. Case managers then scrambled to reach denied applicants before a February 21, 2026 appeal deadline.

Vermont phased out its contractor by March 2026 and took over administration of the program itself, Farnham said.

Mobile home parks bear the brunt

70 VT Households Helped After State Missed 1,700 From FEMA Data, VTDigger
Photo: yahoo.com

Community recovery groups managed several hundred cases after the 2023 floods, said Jason Gosselin, who directs emergency management at the Vermont Agency of Human Services.

Charlotte Hackett, a former state employee who worked on recovery, told The Cool Down, “A lot of folks simply were out of luck by the time we came in.”

FEMA was created under President Jimmy Carter by Presidential Reorganization Plan No. 3 of 1978 and implemented by two Executive Orders on April 1, 1979, consolidating more than 100 separate agencies that had previously jockeyed for control of disaster relief.

Its primary purpose is to coordinate the response to a disaster that overwhelms the resources of local and state authorities, stepping in only after a governor declares a state of emergency and formally requests federal assistance.

The state has not said how many households missed by the outreach still need assistance.