The American Civil Liberties Union of Rhode Island called Wednesday for a major rewrite of the state’s model policy governing automated license plate readers, arguing the guidelines unveiled last month leave police too much discretion to track motorists and retain their data.
In an eight-page analysis sent to State Police Superintendent Col. Darnell Weaver and copied to Gov. Dan McKee, Gov.-elect Helena Foulkes, and law enforcement leadership across the state, ACLU policy associate Madalyn McGunagle wrote that the policy’s shortcomings “warrant careful attention and modification before serving as a model for legislation or ordinance,” Rhode Island Current reported.
The intervention reshapes a debate that has simmered since August, when McKee ordered a statewide pause on new camera installations and gave Weaver 60 days to produce standards amid growing resistance to Flock Safety cameras. The administration released the model policy on Oct. 19 and extended the installation pause indefinitely, leaving binding rules to the General Assembly.
“Given the significant capabilities of these systems, the policy’s shortcomings warrant careful attention and modification before serving as a model for legislation or ordinance.”
Madalyn McGunagle, policy associate for the ACLU of Rhode Island, wrote in the analysis.

The definition that swallows the rule
The ACLU’s central objection targets the policy’s definition of a “valid law enforcement purpose.” The guidance permits camera use for “information/intelligence gathering,” “the prevention of crime,” and “ensuring the safety of the public,” prefaced by the phrase “including, but not limited to.” The ACLU said this language makes the policy’s limits “illusory,” allowing police to justify access to the system for virtually any suspected offense.
Sid Wordell, executive director of the Rhode Island Police Chiefs Association, acknowledged the definition may need clarification but defended the breadth. He told Rhode Island Current that investigations such as hit-and-run crashes and property damage constitute legitimate law enforcement purposes even when they may not involve a crime. “We stand by what has been presented,” Wordell said in an interview.
Retention window draws vendor comparison
The policy requires departments to purge data after 30 days unless it is preserved as part of an investigation. The ACLU pointed out that Flock Safety, the vendor behind many municipal camera networks, revised its own default retention period to seven days on Aug. 13 — less than a quarter of the state model’s allowance.
Wordell defended the longer window, telling Rhode Island Current that cases often surface days or weeks after an incident. “There’s often times that cases are not learned about a day, two days or three days in,” he said. The ACLU countered that because the policy places no cap on how much data can be held for an investigation, retention could approach indefinite.

Audit sampling called ‘woefully inadequate’
The model policy mandates a quarterly audit sampling just 10 browsing inquiries. The ACLU compared that figure to data from Cranston, where a single organizational audit in one month ran more than 150 pages and outside agencies queried the city’s cameras more than 400,000 times. The ACLU called the 10-inquiry sample “woefully inadequate.”
The analysis also flagged the policy’s penalty clause, which states that misuse “may be subject to criminal prosecution, civil liability,” and suspension of access. The ACLU said that no state statute currently makes misuse of a license plate reader a crime, and the word “may” carries significant weight.
Flock cameras could enable facial recognition
McGunagle’s letter raised concerns that Flock-recorded images of drivers and passengers could be used for facial recognition, citing a lawsuit against Cumberland police in which a Flock camera allegedly captured forward-facing photos of a driver. The ACLU also called for tighter restrictions on data sharing between departments and stronger protections against monitoring constitutionally protected activity.
Jon Carvalho, a spokesperson for Foulkes’ transition team, said the governor-elect supports keeping the statewide pause in place until questions about security, privacy, and transparency are resolved. “Once all of those are clear, the state can determine if and how to move forward with any related technology for law enforcement agencies,” Carvalho told Rhode Island Current Thursday.
Officials respond to ACLU recommendations
The League of Cities and Towns confirmed receipt of the analysis and said it planned to review the recommendations. Christine Crocker, executive director of the Rhode Island Police Accreditation Commission, said she had received the letter but had not yet reviewed it. McKee’s office did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the ACLU’s letter.
The ACLU estimates 280 or more cameras are already operating on Rhode Island roads. With the model policy serving as voluntary guidance and no statute on the books, the General Assembly will decide whether the next version of these rules carries the force of law.