New York City, Los Angeles and Chicago are weighing a breakup with Google Search after the company told schools they must accept its generative AI features or lose access to the search engine entirely, The New York Times reported.
The standoff erupted this month when Google informed districts that its AI Overviews and AI Mode are now so “deeply integrated” into Search that no chatbot-free version exists for education customers. Starting next year, the company plans to turn Gemini and AI search features off by default, letting administrators opt in.
But schools that keep AI disabled will see a message telling students the tool is unavailable rather than a clean, traditional search page, a stance that effectively forces districts to choose between Google’s AI and Google’s search.
“We refuse to accept the false binary Google has laid out,” Kamar H. Samuels, chancellor of New York City schools, said in a statement to the Times. “If Google doesn’t reconsider their position, we will explore other search options.”
Jack Kelanic, chief information officer for Los Angeles Unified, put it more bluntly at a recent board meeting: “We have choices. We can change the default search engine literally overnight.”
The infrastructure trap
The threat carries weight because of how thoroughly Google has embedded itself in classroom infrastructure. Chromebooks, Gmail, Docs and Classroom form the backbone of daily instruction in many districts. Search is woven into device configurations, content filtering systems and teacher workflows. Swapping the default engine means reworking all of that at scale — a nontrivial operational lift for systems serving millions of students.

Chicago Public Schools, the nation’s fourth-largest district, said in an email to the Times it is pursuing independent technical controls to suppress AI features. “If such an arrangement can’t be reached, the district will look to other search solutions,” a spokesperson wrote.
Smaller districts are already building workarounds. In Park Hills, Missouri, technology director Chris Warden said his 2,000-student system signed up for a new Lightspeed Systems service designed to block AI Overview and AI Mode inside Google Search. “We need to be able to control our own pace,” Warden told the Times, “not have Google tell us what the pace of AI adoption is going to be.”
Teachers report students skipping reading and bonding with chatbots
Educators’ resistance stems from concrete classroom friction. Teachers report students scanning AI-generated summaries instead of reading primary sources, using embedded chatbots to shortcut assignments, and in some cases developing unhealthy attachments to conversational agents.
A lawsuit filed this month in North Carolina alleges a student developed a suicide plan after prolonged chats with Google’s AI on a school-issued Chromebook. Google said it has built safeguards to surface emergency resources and is reviewing the claims.
Medical associations have warned that relationship-forming chatbots pose mental-health risks for developing minds. Meanwhile, both New York City and Los Angeles imposed moratoriums on student-facing generative AI this fall. New York’s policy bars AI for grades 2-K through 8, limiting high school use to approved, guided contexts.
Google’s counter-narrative
Google frames the change as expanded choice. In a November 3 post on X, the company’s News account stated: “Gemini, Gemini Notebook, and Search will be OFF by default.”
This is based on K-12 schools asking for more control.” A company spokesperson reiterated to the Times that administrators can activate AI Mode, AI Overviews, and a pilot feature called Guided Learning, a chatbot widget designed to break down academic questions without handing over answers.
Jenn Brown, a Google program manager, told school tech leaders in a monthly Meet that the company now considers Search “fundamentally an AI product,” according to an administrator who attended the session. That philosophical shift — Search equals AI — is precisely what districts reject.
Parents take to the streets
Protesters gathered last week outside Google offices in Boston, Boulder, Chicago, New York and Portland. In Chicago, parents and educators chanted, “Hey, Google, nice try, we don’t want your Gemini.”
Cassie Creswell, executive director of Illinois Families for Public Schools, told the Times: “We don’t want corporations determining what is happening in our kids’ classrooms and how our schools are run.” In Venice, California, signs read, “We don’t need Alphabet to teach the alphabet.”
The alternatives waiting in the wings
DuckDuckGo and Microsoft Bing both offer toggle switches to disable AI-generated answers — the granular control districts say Google refuses to provide. But switching is not a homepage setting change. It touches Chromebook management consoles, firewall rules, single sign-on integrations and years of curated teacher resources built around Google’s ecosystem.
Los Angeles board member Nick Melvoin noted a bitter irony: Google’s hard line “undermines the goal of trying to get some AI into schools” by alienating the very educators attempting a measured rollout.
Google LLC, founded in 1998 by Larry Page and Sergey Brin, grew from a search engine into the dominant provider of classroom infrastructure. Its ChromeOS operating system and Workspace suite — including Gmail, Docs and Classroom — form the digital backbone of daily instruction for millions of students, making the search engine nearly inseparable from the devices and workflows districts rely on.
New York City has declined to join Google’s Guided Learning pilot and is instead evaluating five other AI tools for potential high school use. The City Council has formally asked Google whether students can use Search without enabling AI Mode, AI Overviews or other generative features. As of mid-November, the Council said that question had not received a public answer.