Utah students lost access to 36 books across every public school library this year under a law that lets three districts decide for the entire state.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Utah filed Vonnegut v. Utah in U.S. District Court on January 6, challenging the statewide removal mechanism created by HB 29. The suit names the Utah State Board of Education, Attorney General Derek Brown, and three school districts as defendants.
“The freedom to read is a First Amendment right, not a privilege,” the ACLU of Utah said in its announcement of the litigation. “As long as HB 29 continues to operate, pulling celebrated works of literature from students’ hands without regard for their value or their voices, we will be in court fighting to stop it.”
HB 29 took effect July 1, 2024. It expanded the 2022 “Sensitive Materials in Schools Act” (HB 374) by adding a trigger: if three school districts or charter schools classify a title as “objectively sensitive material,” that book disappears from every K–12 public library shelf in Utah. Less than 10 percent of the state’s districts and charters now control what the other 90 percent may offer.
The numbers accelerated fast. During the 2021–2022 school year, Utah schools reported 12 book removals. After HB 374 passed, that figure jumped to 281 the following year. The titles targeted were overwhelmingly written by and about Black, Indigenous, and LGBTQ+ people.
When HB 29’s trigger fired on July 1, it retroactively banned 13 books statewide in a single day. The list has since grown to 36, making Utah the national leader in statewide school-library bans.
The complaint argues the law is unconstitutionally overbroad. By stripping books based solely on the presence of any sexual reference — without weighing literary merit, context, or the age of the reader — the state censors protected speech and silences both students and authors, the filing asserts.
Attorney General Derek Brown took office on January 8, 2025, after winning the November 2024 election. A Republican, he represented House District 49 in the Utah House of Representatives from 2010 to 2014 before becoming deputy chief of staff and state director for U.S. Senator Mike Lee.
Brown also served as legal counsel to Senators Bob Bennett and Orrin Hatch and worked at the international law firms Sidley & Austin and Lincoln Hill Partners. He has taught communications law and ethics as an adjunct professor at Brigham Young University since 2007.
The case asks the court to declare the statewide-ban provisions facially unconstitutional and to order every removed title returned to shelves immediately.