Admission is $10 per adult for guided tours of St. Michael the Archangel Church, while students and children are admitted free, according to Visit Madison.
Pressed against the bluffs at the eastern end of Third Street at 521 E. Third St., the historic structure stands as the second oldest Catholic church in Indiana, nps.gov reported.
Built between 1838 and 1839 and originally completed in 1839, the Gothic Revival structure is the oldest Gothic Revival building in Indiana and is especially notable for its pointed arch windows and unique design that embodies the dreams of immigrants for a better life now and in the world to come.
Legend holds that the church was built using an abundance of stone excavated during the construction of the Madison-Indianapolis Railroad, and a large portion of the original congregation—largely made up of German and Irish immigrants—consisted of laborers who had worked on the railroad’s incline. Among the early parishioners were local architect Francis Costigan alongside William Griffin, the Irish immigrant who finished building the Madison and Indianapolis Railroad Incline.

The south part of the church is the oldest. In 1865, the church’s nave was extended 20 feet to the north, requiring much of the addition to be subterranean so that the stained-glass window high in the apse is just a few feet above grade on the exterior, avoiding disruption to the interior. The most prominent architectural detail of the interior is its ogee-arch, or “open book,” ceiling.
The rectory building just west of the church was constructed between 1859 and 1860 from rubble-stone masonry finished with tooled stucco to resemble ashlar stone, featuring Greek Revival styling typical of Madison architecture. Priests of St. Michael’s resided in the rectory until 1932, and it has remained vacant since that time.
The National Park Service’s Historic American Buildings Survey has recorded both structures, which also enhance the historical importance of the Madison Historic District—a designated National Historic Landmark and a property listed on the National Register of Historic Places.
The building functioned as a Catholic church until 1993, when the Indianapolis Archdiocese donated it to Historic Madison, Inc. as part of a parish consolidation. Historic Madison, Inc. has continued to preserve and protect the building for more than 30 years.
All Historic Madison, Inc. tours are guided, and the church is owned by the organization. During the off-season from November through April, tours are available by request only with no scheduled tours. Private tours require 72 hours’ advance notice by appointment. Visitors can check the Historic Madison website or call 812-265-2967 for more information.