Advance Colorado, GOP Senators Sue to Block Colorado Tiered Income Tax System

Advance Colorado and two Republican state senators sued the state in Denver District Court Thursday, asking a judge to block the new tiered income tax system approved by voters this month.

The complaint argues Amendment 87 violated the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights by bundling a constitutional change with a statutory tax increase and by giving voters misleading ballot information.

The legal challenge arrives after Colorado voters narrowly approved Amendment 87, with 52 percent in favor and 48 percent opposed. The measure raises corporate and individual income tax rates on the top 3 percent of earners, while the 97 percent of Coloradans who earn less than $500,000 a year receive a slight income tax reduction.

Together with Proposition NN, which raised the TABOR revenue cap, the amendment marked the most sweeping set of changes to Colorado tax policy since voters enacted TABOR in 1992.

“TABOR is a citizen-initiated constitutional measure that requires proposed tax increases be presented to the people through a clear ballot question and an accurate notice so that voters are not confused or misinformed when they vote,” the lawsuit reads.

The single-subject argument

The complaint centers on a procedural claim: that Amendment 87 should have been filed as two separate measures. By striking the constitutional requirement for a flat income tax and simultaneously imposing a new graduated rate structure, the initiative combined a constitutional amendment with a statutory tax hike, the plaintiffs argue.

Advance Colorado, GOP Senators Sue to Block Colorado Tiered Income Tax System
Photo: yahoo.com

“The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned.” Sen. Byron Pelton of Sterling is the other legislative plaintiff.

The suit also alleges that the 2026 state voter guide included tables that miscalculated some tax changes and misstated how the new revenue would be used. It cites recent comments from Gov. Jared Polis suggesting the additional revenue could be consumed by growth in the state’s Medicaid budget.

A campaign claim disappears

Notably absent from the lawsuit is the claim that dominated opposition messaging in recent months: that Amendment 87 would eliminate tax deductions for Social Security income, veterans’ pensions and other forms of income. Fact checkers repeatedly debunked that assertion during the campaign. Advance Colorado did not respond to inquiries about whether it still asserts those deductions will disappear when the amendment takes effect Jan. 1.

“When people see the economic destruction that Amendment 87 will cause, they will want immediate reform,” said Michael Fields, president of Advance Colorado. “Exempting the first $100,000 of income for individuals and businesses will make Colorado more competitive and will put more money in people’s pockets.”

The 2027 counterplay

On the same day it filed suit, Advance Colorado submitted four proposed ballot initiatives for the 2027 election. All four would re-establish a top income tax rate of 4.4 percent for higher brackets. Two versions would exempt all income under $100,000 from state income taxes; the other two would exempt the first $50,000 and tax the next $50,000 at 3.71 percent.

Sen. Byron Pelton of Sterling, a Republican representing northeast Colorado’s 1st Senate district, was elected Logan County commissioner in 2016 and re-elected in 2020 before winning the Senate seat unopposed in 2022. A United States Navy veteran trained as an electrician repairing ships damaged in Desert Storm, he worked as a Master Electrician for 20 years and was named Colorado Commissioner of the Year in 2021.

The group has opposed the measure at every stage, challenging it at the Title Board, suing the secretary of state to remove it from the ballot — a case decided just days before Election Day — and backing Proposition 136, a competing measure to cap rates at current levels. Voters rejected Proposition 136.