“The NCAA’s imposition of policies, rules, and regulations on each of its member institutions across the country, including its 18 member institutions in Alabama, alone cannot support a finding that it has purposefully directed any activities toward Alabama that connect it with Pruitt and his lawsuit,” the Alabama Supreme Court wrote in its 93-page ruling Friday.
The court dismissed former Tennessee coach Jeremy Pruitt’s $100 million lawsuit against the NCAA in a 5-3 decision that leaves his six-year show-cause penalty intact through July 2029.
The ruling, reported by AL.com, means Pruitt cannot pursue damages or permanent relief from the NCAA restrictions in DeKalb County. The high court ordered the DeKalb Circuit Court to vacate its order denying the NCAA’s motion to dismiss, ruling that Alabama was not the proper venue because the investigation and disciplinary proceedings occurred in Tennessee, Indiana and Ohio.
Justice Will Sellers, concurring in the result, wrote that the law demands “a meaningful connection between the defendant’s forum-directed conduct and the particular controversy the plaintiff raises.” Justice Tom Bryan disagreed, noting that the NCAA sent its show-cause order to 18 member institutions in Alabama.
Bryan said those hiring restrictions were directly linked to Pruitt’s claim that the NCAA interfered with his job prospects. Justice Jean Brown Wise joined Bryan’s dissent, and Justice Jay Mitchell Parker wrote a separate dissent.

The NCAA issued the show-cause penalty in July 2023 after charging Pruitt’s Tennessee program with 18 violations involving 29 recruits and 10 active players. Investigators found impermissible benefits of more than $60,000 in cash and other benefits paid to recruits before name, image and likeness rules were legalized in July 2021. Tennessee fired Pruitt in January 2021 after a 15-19 record with the Volunteers.
The penalty includes a one-year suspension from all team activities if any school hires him before the order expires on July 13, 2029 — a restriction that effectively made him unhirable at the college level.
Nick Saban tried to bring Pruitt back to Alabama in 2023 before Saban’s final season, but the show-cause blocked the move, according to AL.com. Pruitt served as Alabama’s defensive backs coach from 2010 to 2012 and defensive coordinator in 2016 and 2017, with coordinator stops at Florida State and Georgia in between.
Pruitt filed the lawsuit in DeKalb County on March 26, 2025, more than four years after his firing. He charged that the NCAA and Tennessee worked together to blame him for violations he said predated his tenure. A DeKalb County judge granted Pruitt a temporary injunction last December preventing the NCAA from enforcing the ban, but the NCAA appealed to the state supreme court.

Jacksonville State hired Pruitt as an analyst in 2025 after the NCAA modified the order to allow the employment under certain conditions. Pruitt resigned from Jacksonville State on March 31, 2026. In April, at his request, the DeKalb court lifted the preliminary injunction that had temporarily blocked enforcement of the order.
With Friday’s dismissal, Pruitt will be unable to coach in college football until the show-cause order expires in 2029.