Albany Lawmakers Eye 12% Tax Hike, Rejecting Mayor’s 15% Proposal

Albany lawmakers are steering toward a 12% property tax increase, well below the 15% hike Mayor Dorcey Applyrs proposed, after Council Finance Chair Megan Keegan told WAMC the votes simply do not exist to override the state tax cap at the higher level.

The Common Council introduced two bills Monday night: one capping the override at 12%, the other at 13.5%. The mayor backs the 13.5% option, but Keegan said the 12% version has the nine votes needed to pass.

“It’s the worst possible thing that could happen,” Keegan told WAMC, describing a scenario where the council fails to override the cap yet residents still get hit with the full 15% increase — money the city could not legally spend until 2028.

“The best course of action for the council legally may be to just not act on the proposed budget, with the exception of addressing the property tax levy itself, and allow the administration to carry their proposed spending plan and essentially be responsible for their proposed spending plan.”

Keegan said.

If the 12% figure holds, the $257 million budget absorbs another $1.6 million in cuts on top of the $9 million Applyrs has already proposed. Because the city’s 300-year-old charter denies the council line-item veto power, the mayor would choose where those additional cuts fall. Keegan argued the council lacks both the legal mechanism and the internal consensus to dictate spending reductions anyway.

The charter’s age is the subplot driving the frustration. Councilmember Tom Hoey called for a referendum on charter reform as early as November 2025. “We need to look at this charter and try to get it fixed so that we’re not taking the blame for a process that was invented 300 years ago,” Hoey said.

The council also wants former budget director Gideon Grande — now Schenectady County’s budget director — to testify on how the city reached this fiscal cliff, though they cannot compel him.

A deal is expected Thursday.