Chris Columbus wanted Joe Pesci and Daniel Stern as his Wet Bandits, but the studio would only pay for one of them.
So Columbus took Pesci and the production hired another actor for Marv. Four days into filming, Columbus fired him — the only person he has ever let go in a career that spans Home Alone, Mrs. Doubtfire, and the first two Harry Potter films.
The director told the story on the Wildmen podcast, hosted by his son Brendan and actor Dylan Sprouse. “We did a screen test, and they were horrible,” Columbus said.
“I mean, Pesci was great. This other kid was… just awful. And that’s the only person I ever had to fire.” He described the actor as “a kid at the time” and, trying to soften the blow, promised they would work together again. They never did.
Columbus didn’t name the actor on the podcast, but Daniel Roebuck identified himself as the original Marv in a 2023 episode of the What a Character! podcast. “I was never, ever, ever going to film as Marv,” Roebuck said.
“I got the wettest handshake of my life with [writer and producer] John Hughes. It was the most disappointing handshake I ever received because I was a fan of the guy. And he clearly didn’t want me to be there. It was all so obvious.”

Roebuck said Columbus made the same future-work promise on the day he was fired. “Chris Columbus said I will give you a great part of my next movie,” Roebuck recalled. “Now, I notice he’s done 20 since then, and he’s never called. But what really was disappointing was, you know, no one ever just told me the truth.”
After firing Roebuck, the production hired Stern anyway and still had to pay Roebuck for his time. The miscalculation cost more than simply hiring both Pesci and Stern from the start.
“We didn’t have Dan Stern because the studio wouldn’t pay for Dan Stern,” Columbus told the Wildmen podcast. “I conceived of Dan Stern and Joe Pesci in this movie as the bad guys. And they said, ‘You only get one.’ So I said, ‘Okay, let’s go with Pesci.’”
Roebuck, who went on to appear in more than 277 projects including The Fugitive, Agent Cody Banks, Matlock, Nash Bridges, and Glee, said he felt the decision had been made before he ever stepped on set.
Columbus, now 68, framed the firing as a chemistry problem rather than a talent deficit.
Chris Columbus said the studio would only pay for Joe Pesci, so they hired another actor for Marv, but after about four days of filming Daniel Roebuck was fired because he and Pesci had no chemistry, and Columbus promised they would work together in the future, a promise that never materialized.