Appeals Court Pauses Iowa Army Plan to Detonate Five Tons of Lead Azide

The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals hit pause on the Environmental Protection Agency’s emergency permit late Thursday, casting immediate doubt on whether the U.S. Army can move forward with plans to detonate roughly five tons of unstable lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in Middletown on Monday.

The stay, granted while the court weighs an emergency motion from the Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club’s Iowa chapter, freezes the EPA permit that had authorized the controlled burns. Earthjustice senior attorney Thien Chau said Friday the court could rule before Monday but offered no timetable.

“It does truly feel unprecedented, right? Taking this much explosive that contains lead, and to blow it up, knowing that it is going to disperse over communities, over farmland, over water bodies — including one of the most iconic water bodies in this country, the Mississippi River — and possibly affect more than one state,” Chau said. “I think it absolutely is an abnormal and extraordinary thing to do.”

Lead azide detonation in Iowa by U.S. Army paused indefinitely — CBS Chicago

The Justice Department fired back Friday, filing notice that it will oppose the environmental groups’ request. Government lawyers argue the deteriorating explosive poses an “imminent and substantial danger to human health and the environment” and pointed to a federal regulation allowing waste treatment without an EPA permit in qualifying emergencies involving an immediate threat to people, property, or the environment.

Chau called that exception an “extraordinary and extreme backstop” and urged the Army not to invoke it to bypass the court proceedings, noting the Army cannot rely on the suspended permit to carry out the blasts.

The material at issue sits in 68 drums at the plant near Burlington. Lead azide is a primary explosive used to initiate munitions; the Army says recrystallization has made the stored supply highly sensitive to friction and shock, creating what the EPA describes as an “unacceptable risk of unintentional detonation” if the containers are disturbed.

Because of the risks in packing and transporting it, the Army maintains that “safely destroying it in place is the only responsible option.”

Army delays detonation of 5 tons of lead azide in Iowa — NBC Chicago

The environmental groups argue the EPA gave residents too little notice and failed to require a full review of alternatives or adequate testing and cleanup. Their motion says lead dust could travel 100 miles or more under some weather conditions.

They want the Army to take a closer look at chemical neutralization, a technology described in an EPA compendium. The Army counters that chemical treatment would require prolonged handling of the 68 drums, increasing the risk of an accidental explosion.

“The groups want to protect workers as well as people who could be exposed to lead dust,”

Michael Schmidt, general counsel for the Iowa Environmental Council, said.

Wally Taylor, legal chair of the Sierra Club’s Iowa chapter, said he wants the Army to provide more evidence that the material must be destroyed immediately.

Justice Department to oppose bid to block the US Army's lead detonation in Iowa
Photo: europesays.com

Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle announced Thursday the detonations would move from Friday to Monday, saying Monday was the latest the Army could wait before a forecast drop in temperatures that could make the explosive more unstable. He did not announce a time for Monday’s operation. The postponement followed calls from lawmakers in both parties for more answers about health risks and safety precautions.

Illinois Gov. JB Pritzker, U.S. Sens. Tammy Duckworth and Dick Durbin, U.S. Reps. Eric Sorensen, Darin LaHood and Mary Miller, and U.S. Sens.-elect Josh Turek of Iowa and Julianna Stratton of Illinois signed a bipartisan letter urging Telle and EPA Administrator Lee Zeldin to consider a delay while safer options are explored.

Gov. Kim Reynolds announced late Friday she has activated the State Emergency Operations Center to coordinate the state response to the planned Monday detonation. The activation creates a hub for state agencies to organize ahead of the controlled explosion.

That came after the Iowa Emergency Management Association called on Reynolds earlier Friday to activate the SEOC, issue a disaster emergency proclamation for potentially affected counties and put Iowa Homeland Security and Emergency Management in charge of coordinating the response. The association said local officials need clear guidance on protective steps and post-blast monitoring even as they await more federal information.

The governor’s office said Friday it is “actively coordinating with federal officials from the Environmental Protection Agency and Army to continuously monitor the situation and keep local partners informed.”

The Department of Health and Human Services, the EPA, and the Army said in a joint statement Friday that agencies involved are prepared to take the “most extreme mitigation measures available to ensure there is no risk to the public and any disruptions are minimized.” The statement said officials had been preparing for the event since March.

As of Friday evening, the Eighth Circuit’s administrative stay remains in effect until the court rules on the motion for a longer-term halt.

The Justice Department’s opposition brief signals the federal government intends to fight for the detonation to proceed, potentially invoking the emergency regulatory exception if the permit remains blocked. Whether the blasts go forward Monday now rests with a federal appeals court weighing an unprecedented collision of explosive safety and environmental law.