Archbishop Paul Coakley delivered his second presidential address to the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops at the start of the public session Tuesday (Nov. 17) that avoided the two crises defining the U.S. Catholic Church right now — the conference’s refusal to implement Pope Francis’s teaching on family life and the Trump administration’s mass deportation of Catholic migrants.
National Catholic Reporter described the speech as “deadly dull,” noting Coakley downplayed divisions while the bishops’ conference headquarters in Washington sits half empty, a metaphor the outlet argued fits an institution that has slowed Francis’s initiatives to a crawl.
Coakley mentioned attending a Rome meeting last month on the tenth anniversary of Amoris Laetitia, Francis’s apostolic exhortation on the family, but omitted that the U.S. conference has done nothing to receive or implement it.
“There were no contentious arguments, no haggling for points to be made, no bitter disputes,” Coakley said of the Rome gathering, adding that bishops met “to share our experiences around the simple question — what is the state of marriage and family life?” He said the fruits of those discussions would come later, pending the Holy Father’s response.
National Catholic Reporter wrote that the conference is distinguished now for its ability to put a wet blanket on any initiatives, to focus almost exclusively on the internal life of the church, to slow walk the initiatives Pope Francis began.

Religion News Service reported a different emphasis from the same event. Coakley told reporters the bishops are “committed” to working with the Trump administration and the Democratic majority in Congress, saying, “If we can find something in common with virtually anybody on the Hill that is willing to work with us, we’re willing to work with them.”
He framed the church’s mission as distinct from politics: “The world thinks in terms of power,” he said, while “the church thinks in terms of mission.”
The migrant omission
Last year the conference adopted a statement opposing “indiscriminate mass deportation” and released a video of bishops reading it that drew more than 100,000 views. This year, Coakley did not mention migrants in his address.
National Catholic Reporter said that barely a week has passed without a story of Catholics defending migrants — Chicago Catholics fighting for pastoral access to ICE detention centers, the Archdiocese of St. Louis suing for access to detainees, and Catholics in the Twin Cities protecting migrants after ICE shot and killed two people.
At a press conference in Brownsville, Texas, Vice President Bishop Daniel Flores offered a sharper assessment: “We’re in a moment when the Church seems to have to defend her public works of justice and charity,” Flores said, adding that serving people is an essential part of the Church’s religious liberty.
Coakley listed strengthening the family, worship, and synodality as conference priorities. He called for a “new vision of how to prepare and accompany couples, beyond marriage preparation programs, beyond the wedding day, into fully and fruitfully living out a life-long commitment.”
At the press conference he elaborated: “If we wait until it’s time for prenuptial or pre-marriage instruction, it’s too late. It needs to be modeled and lived in the home and in the family.”
Asked about the greatest threat to living as a Catholic in the U.S., Coakley cited G.K. Chesterton before naming the “human heart” and the need for “personal renewal.”
Coakley challenges Trump on immigration and execution plans
Coakley, who serves as ecclesiastical adviser to the conservative Napa Institute, has previously criticized the Trump administration’s immigration policy and opposed a plan to livestream the execution of the Fort Hood shooter.
In a letter to Trump he wrote, “What good is the immense wealth, prosperity, and influence with which we have been blessed as a nation if not used in service of our humanity?” urging a halt to mass deportations of Haitian immigrants.
The Rome meeting’s proceedings remain unpublished. The Holy Father’s response is still awaited.