The Arkansas Supreme Court overturned longstanding legal precedent on Thursday, Nov. 5, ruling that state lawmakers possess the constitutional authority to let childhood sexual abuse survivors file civil lawsuits even after the original filing deadlines have expired, according to KATV.
The ruling directly reverses a lower court’s decision that previously dismissed a lawsuit against former Little Rock pediatrician James Darrell Nesmith. Four plaintiffs accuse Nesmith of abusing them as children between 1995 and 2007 during medical visits, at his home, or at a camp run by Covenant Presbyterian Church, where Nesmith served as a deacon, youth director, and Boy Scouts troop leader.
“And we now restore to the General Assembly its constitutional power to decide how long is too long to bring a claim,” Justice Nicholas Bronni wrote in the majority opinion.
The lawsuit initially fell apart because the statute of limitations had run out. However, the high court’s new interpretation revives the claim under the Justice for Vulnerable Victims of Sexual Abuse Act, a measure passed by the General Assembly in 2021.
Advocacy groups quickly praised the decision for acknowledging the real-world timeline of trauma recovery. Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests, known as SNAP, issued a statement welcoming the move.
“The justices in Arkansas have ruled on the side of fairness for childhood survivors,” said Angela Walker, SNAP Survivors Network Executive Director. “It takes survivors decades to come forward, often out of fear and repression, and the court system in Arkansas has removed a longstanding and unreasonable obstacle in their path to accountability.”
Walker added that the organization hopes other state legislatures nationwide follow suit by hearing the cases of survivors who summon the courage to speak out, regardless of how much time has passed.
“SNAP hopes that state legislators around the nation see the merits of simply hearing the cases of survivors who have the courage to come forward, no matter how long it takes,” Walker told Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. “It’s the height of unfairness to penalize survivors for the length of time the mind takes to process trauma.”
Not all members of the court agreed with the sweeping change. Chief Justice Karen Baker and Justice Shawn Womack dissented from the majority opinion.
Womack wrote that the ruling breaks sharply with historical judicial norms. “The majority departs from nearly two centuries of our vested-rights jurisprudence,” Womack wrote, according to KATV.
The Supreme Court’s decision does not decide whether Nesmith is guilty of the alleged abuse. Instead, the ruling simply returns the case to a lower court for further proceedings, leaving the ultimate merits of the allegations yet to be tested in a courtroom.