The Illinois Supreme Court ruled Thursday that Gregory Johnson Jr. deserves a retrospective hearing to decide whether he was mentally fit when he pleaded guilty to murder in 2019, a decision that simultaneously resurrects plain-error review for defendants who plead guilty.
Justice Cunningham wrote the lead opinion in People v. Johnson, 2026 IL 130932, joined by Justices Rochford and O’Brien. Chief Justice Neville and Justice Overstreet filed special concurrences; Justice Holder White dissented; Justice Tailor took no part. The court affirmed the Fifth District’s judgment vacating the circuit court’s fitness finding and remanding for a new hearing, the Illinois State Bar Association reported.
The ruling matters immediately for every pending criminal appeal in Illinois. By overruling People v. Ratliff (2024) on the key point that an omitted issue in a Rule 604(d) post-plea motion is “waived” rather than “forfeited,” the court restored the ability of appellate courts to review unpreserved claims for plain error — effective today.
“The merger rule brings up for review the earlier nonfinal orders that were steps in the procedural progression leading to the final judgment,” Cunningham wrote, rejecting the State’s argument that the appellate court lacked jurisdiction because Johnson’s notice of appeal named only the denial of his motion to withdraw his plea.
An order finding a defendant restored to fitness is not immediately appealable, she noted, and a defendant cannot be prosecuted while unfit, so the restoration order merges into the final judgment.
The case began in October 2017, when Johnson was charged with stabbing Timothy Ellis to death after deciding Ellis had molested a friend’s 16-year-old daughter. At arraignment Johnson interrupted proceedings, saying he wanted to “plead innocent” and “plead insanity.” Two months later his attorney moved for a fitness examination under section 104-11(b) of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
The court granted the motion on January 5, 2018, and ordered Dr. David Coleman to evaluate Johnson. At a March 29 hearing the parties stipulated to the doctor’s report — which never made it into the court file — and the court entered an agreed order finding Johnson unfit. He was sent to Chester Mental Health Center.
The Center’s records tell a story of diagnostic chaos. An initial plan diagnosed paranoid schizophrenia and antisocial personality disorder. By August 2018 the Center reported Johnson had “no rational understanding of court proceedings.”
An October 22 treatment-plan review changed the primary diagnosis to adult oppositional defiant disorder, stated Johnson had been found fit on September 24, yet also listed fitness as an “active” treatment goal with a target date of December 30 and declared the team “currently believes that [Johnson] is Unfit to Stand Trial.”
Nonetheless, on October 30 the circuit court ordered Johnson released from the Center and remanded to the county jail, citing a progress report stating he was fit — a report that was not attached to the order and is not in the record. The Center discharged him November 1 with a one-page “Notice of Change in Status” recommending him as fit.
At a November 14 restoration hearing the court had the notice but no progress report. Defense counsel proposed stipulating that “the doctor who wrote the report” would testify consistently with it. The court asked, “Which is restoring him to fitness [?]” and counsel agreed. The State joined the stipulation. No witnesses testified, no one questioned Johnson, and the report was never placed in the record.
Johnson pleaded guilty in March 2019 under a fully negotiated agreement for 45 years. He later filed a pro se motion to withdraw his plea, denied as untimely. The Fourth District reversed and remanded for a ruling on the merits. Appointed counsel filed an amended motion alleging Johnson had been denied medication from November 2018 until the plea and that plea counsel was ineffective for proceeding without determining competence.
The motion attached the Center’s reports, part of the plea transcript, and Johnson’s affidavit stating that without medication he “was not thinking clearly” at the time of his plea. The motion mentioned the November 2018 restoration hearing only in its background and did not allege the restoration finding was erroneous.
The court denied the motion. The Fifth District reviewed for plain error, found the trial court had relied on the stipulation without ensuring Johnson could understand the proceedings and assist in his defense, vacated the restoration order, and remanded for a retrospective fitness hearing.
The Supreme Court’s lead opinion held Johnson had not preserved the challenge to the restoration order because his amended motion targeted the plea hearing, not the restoration hearing. Plain-error review is therefore available in appeals following guilty pleas, effective immediately and applying to all cases pending in the appellate court and the Supreme Court.
The lead opinion added a limit: plain-error review cannot raise claims that a knowing and voluntary guilty plea waives under the waiver-by-guilty-plea doctrine.
On the merits, the lead opinion rejected the State’s reliance on People v. Lewis, 103 Ill. 2d 111 (1984). Lewis allows a court to accept a stipulation to an expert’s expected opinion testimony, not a stipulation to the legal conclusion that the defendant is fit.
The stipulation here did not name the doctor, state his qualifications, describe how he examined Johnson, explain how Johnson was restored after a diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia, address whether his fitness depended on medication, or establish that he could understand the proceedings and assist in his defense. It was “so vague as to have essentially no evidentiary value,” the court concluded.
The court affirmed the appellate court’s judgment and remanded for a retrospective fitness hearing. If Johnson’s fitness at the time of the plea can be fairly and accurately determined from the contemporaneous record, the appellate court will retain jurisdiction under Rule 615(b)(2) to address his self-representation claim. If not, he is entitled to a new trial.
Justice Cunningham delivered the judgment; Justices Rochford and O’Brien concurred.