Blue Jays Fill 40-Man Roster, Protect Perry, Guerra, Schreck from Rule 5 Draft

The Toronto Blue Jays moved to secure their farm system depth on Tuesday, selecting the contracts of right-handed pitchers Nolan Perry and Daniel Guerra and outfielder RJ Schreck to the 40-man roster.

The deadline-day transactions bring Toronto’s roster to its 40-man capacity, effectively shielding the trio from the Rule 5 Draft currently scheduled for December 9 in San Diego, as reported by MLB.

The decision to fill the roster reflects a calculated front-office effort to retain talent that the organization views as capable of contributing in the immediate future.

Because the 40-man roster is now full, any subsequent offseason acquisitions or trades will necessitate corresponding roster moves, such as designating a player for assignment or clearing space through further transactions.

Perry’s Path to Protection

Nolan Perry emerges as the most significant addition, ranking No. 2 in the Blue Jays’ system and No. 90 on the MLB Top 100 list. His ascent is particularly notable given that he missed the entire 2025 season following UCL repair surgery.

According to Sportsnet.ca, the 23-year-old rebounded in 2026 by posting a 2.50 ERA with 117 strikeouts across 82 2/3 innings, climbing through three levels of the minors.

The front office’s decision to protect Perry aligns with historical league trends; per Sports Illustrated, every Top 100 prospect eligible for the Rule 5 Draft over the past 11 years has been protected by their respective organization.

Guerra Adds Velocity and Strikeouts to Bullpen

Daniel Guerra, the club’s No. 15 prospect, rounds out the pitching additions. The 22-year-old Venezuelan right-hander, signed for $40,000 in 2022, demonstrated significant growth in 2026, reaching Triple-A Buffalo while recording 107 strikeouts in 78 1/3 innings. Blue Jays Nation notes that Guerra’s fastball has reached 99.5 mph, though his command—evidenced by eight walks in 9.1 innings at the Triple-A level—remains a focal point for his continued development.

RJ Schreck provides the organization with needed outfield depth. Acquired from the Seattle Mariners in the 2024 trade for Justin Turner, the 26-year-old offers a high-floor profile characterized by strong on-base metrics. Despite an injury-shortened 2026 campaign, Schreck has maintained a .383 on-base percentage throughout his minor-league career, per MLB.

Top Prospects Left Exposed for Rule 5 Draft

The future of the December 9 draft remains in flux as the expiration of the Collective Bargaining Agreement on December 1 looms. Multiple outlets, including MLB Trade Rumors, suggest that a potential labor stoppage could lead to the cancellation of the draft, mirroring the outcome of the 2021 offseason.

Despite the potential for the draft to be scrapped, Toronto opted to leave several high-ranking prospects exposed.

Notable names omitted from the 40-man roster include right-hander Gage Stanifer (No. 9), infielder Josh Kasevich (No. 13), and utility player Jay Harry (No. 21). The organization’s willingness to risk these players suggests a prioritization of current projectability over total system coverage, a strategy that could be tested if the draft proceeds as scheduled.

Player Position 2026 System Rank
Nolan Perry RHP No. 2
RJ Schreck OF No. 12
Daniel Guerra RHP No. 15

As the offseason progresses, the Blue Jays are expected to continue evaluating the outfield and starting pitching markets. With the 40-man roster currently at capacity, the front office faces limited flexibility, potentially setting the stage for further administrative moves before the start of Spring Training.

Disclaimer: The analytical insights and data provided in this article are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute medical advice or sports betting recommendations.

American League pitcher Nolan Perry throws in the third inning during the MLB All-Star Futures baseball game against
Photo: Sportsnet.ca