Blue Sucker Lives 131 Years, Tripling Previous Estimates, Study Finds

A fish swimming in the Upper Missouri River today hatched before Montana was a state, before the Titanic sank, and before the Model T rolled off the line.

Researchers have confirmed that blue suckers in Montana are living to 130 years old — more than triple the 40-year ceiling biologists had assumed for decades.

The finding, published in Communications Biology, rewrites the life history of a native species listed as imperiled in 22 of the 23 states where it still exists. "For decades, there has been conservation concern for the species across much of its range," the researchers wrote. "Nonetheless, no validated age-based life history information exists for the species, which is a major knowledge gap."

Lackmann’s team collected 42 blue suckers from 2023 to 2026, sectioning their otoliths — tiny earstones that lay down annual rings like tree trunks. Under the microscope, the rings told a story no one expected: maximum age 131 years, 70 years beyond the previous estimate. “In these otoliths from fish previously thought to live to about 40 years, we were seeing the population had ages up to 130 years old,” Lackmann told Phys.org.

To prove the rings weren’t lying, the lab turned to bomb radiocarbon dating. Thermonuclear tests in the 1950s and early 1960s doubled atmospheric radiocarbon, leaving a timestamp in any organism alive at the time. The otolith chemistry matched the “bomb pulse” curve, validating the extreme ages.

“Bomb radiocarbon dating is one of the best ways to age-validate long-lived organisms,” Lackmann said. “So that’s where we have multiple lines of evidence here, otoliths providing the age estimates, and bomb radiocarbon confirming and validating the otolith ages and extreme longevity of the blue sucker.”

A fish as old as monta
Photo: soz6.com

“To put a timeline on some of those older fish: the oldest one hatched around two years after Montana became a state, around the dawn of the automobile, like 20 years before the Titanic sank — it’s just wild,” said Holmquist.

“We start putting it in the context of what the landscape looked like when these fish hatched, and all the changes that have happened since — and they just keep swimming along in the river.”

The demographic snapshot is even more alarming than the longevity. Between 64 and 76 percent of the sampled fish hatched before Fort Peck Dam closed its gates in 1940, before Canyon Ferry Dam in 1954, and before Tiber Dam in 1956.

In three decades of monitoring, virtually no young blue suckers have been detected entering the population. The study concludes recruitment failure is “more likely in the post-dam era,” implicating habitat fragmentation and altered flow regimes as the primary suspects.

This mirrors Lackmann’s earlier work on buffalofishes (Ictiobus spp.), which revealed three species exceeding 100-year lifespans and similar recruitment collapses downstream of major dams. The blue sucker now joins bigmouth buffalo, smallmouth buffalo, and black buffalo as the fourth centenarian catostomid documented since 2019 — a whole guild of ancient fish hiding in plain sight.

Conservation status across the range reads like a roll call of crisis: presumed extirpated in Pennsylvania; critically imperiled in New Mexico, Nebraska, Alabama, and West Virginia; imperiled in Montana, Oklahoma, Wisconsin, Illinois, Tennessee, and Ohio; vulnerable in the remaining dozen states. Only Indiana rates the species “apparently secure.”

The irony is sharp: a fish built to outlive most humans is vanishing because it cannot reproduce in a river remade for human engineering. Dams block the long-distance migrations blue suckers need to spawn, and they flatten the spring floods that cue reproduction. The adults persist — tough, long-lived, waiting — but the next generation never arrives.

Managers now face a dilemma baked into the biology. Traditional fisheries models assumed a 40-year turnover; harvest limits, habitat restoration timelines, and recovery plans were calibrated to a ghost.

If a female blue sucker doesn’t reach peak fecundity until deep into her eighth decade, losing a single big fish erases centuries of reproductive potential. “Increased fecundity with size” was one of the study’s validated findings, meaning the oldest, largest fish are the most valuable — and the most vulnerable to bycatch or poaching.

Lackmann’s team also documented sexually dimorphic growth and age-dependent spot pigmentation, giving field biologists non-lethal ways to estimate age structure without sacrificing the few remaining adults. But the core problem remains hydrological, not methodological.

The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and Bureau of Reclamation operate the mainstem dams that fragment the Upper Missouri. Neither agency has publicly responded to the study. Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, which partnered on the research, has not announced regulatory changes.

The paper stops at diagnosis: “Our findings redefine our understanding of blue sucker, parallel recent population demographic discoveries for buffalofishes, and further identify the diversity of the centenarian catostomid guild.”

The Upper Missouri River begins near Three Forks, Montana, on the eastern slope of the Rockies and runs more than 2,500 miles to the Mississippi at St. Louis. Congress designated the 149-mile stretch from Fort Benton to the James Kipp Recreation Area as a National Wild and Scenic River in 1976.

Lewis and Clark spent three weeks exploring that segment in 1805; today it is considered the premier component of the Lewis & Clark National Historic Trail. The river holds forty-nine fish species, including the endangered pallid sturgeon and a paddlefish population noted for the largest average size of the six remaining in the United States.

What happens next is an open question. Dam removal or modified operations could restore connectivity, but each project takes decades and billions. In the meantime, the fish keep swimming — survivors of a river that no longer makes room for their children.