Hemlock, a downtown Boise steakhouse open barely 18 months, fed the ESPN College GameDay crew on live national television Saturday after a five-day scramble that compressed a typical catering timeline into roughly 36 hours of real decision-making.
The segment lasted about 13 seconds. Host Pat McAfee bit into a tomahawk steak by the bone, then reached into a Broncos helmet stuffed with baked potatoes and caviar to feed a co-host. By Monday, reservation volume had doubled heading into the holiday season.
“We had 13 seconds to show the country, to show Boise, what we do and what we’re capable of,” executive chef Kiel Ard said.
The invitation landed Monday, Nov. 9. A GameDay production coordinator asked Boise restaurants to pitch four platters that captured their kitchens. Proposals were due by midday Wednesday. Ard spent his commute that morning calling purveyors to lock down the largest Idaho potatoes available and put tomahawk ribeyes on hold.
The Menu That Made the Trip
Hemlock built the spread around its two signatures: big steaks and bigger potatoes. The first platter held seven tomahawk steaks with the restaurant’s sauces and compound butters. The second leaned on Hemlock’s tableside baked-potato cart — a dining-room showpiece — recreated inside a Broncos helmet that producers loved when Ard pitched it.
A tableside bowl fit the helmet perfectly; a smashed potato anchored the base, and the kitchen finished it with garnishes and what Ard called “a copious amount of caviar.”

The third platter paired the chicken-fried lobster tail, a popular appetizer, with the 1,000-layer duck-fat potatoes that earned a Forbes mention, plus broccolini. Dessert was The Baked Idaho, Hemlock’s riff on a baked Alaska: huckleberry cake under potato ice cream, torched meringue, and a crisp potato tuile. The pastry team infuses the ice cream with potato starch and bits of potato chip for a subtle salt-and-cream essence.
Chaos Behind the Cameras
GameDay provided no kitchen. Ard arrived at Hemlock around 4:30 a.m. Saturday to start the massive potatoes, with predawn runs to a 24-hour grocery for last-minute items.
The crew assembled at 6 a.m. Tomahawks came off the broiler, potatoes out of the ovens, everything into hot boxes for the six-minute drive to the ESPN loading zone at Boise State. They had one 8-foot table, cables and crew everywhere, and four platters to plate.
“Even though there’s the hype about this being ESPN, at the end of the day, it was still business,” Ard said. “We still treated it like it was a catering event.”
Amy Payne, chief of staff for Apex Brand Collection — the group that owns Hemlock and Spitfire Tacos + Tequila — ran the timeline with checklists. “I wanted it so bad, so I just started orchestrating,” she said. “He does all the magic, but I can keep him in line.”
Right before air, Ard stuffed a pocket with coarse salt and sprinkled it over the steaks on camera. Payne said the hosts loved it.
Local Ownership, National Proof
Co-founder Scott Slater, who also owns Spitfire with Todd Ketlinski, had been traveling that week and missed the broadcast after his Friday flight was grounded. He watched from afar, but he knew the stakes. GameDay had not broadcast from Boise in 16 years. Being the restaurant chosen to represent the city after such a short run felt like confirmation.
“That’s their corner that you’re occupying,” Slater said of Treasure Valley diners. “That’s their restaurant that you’re occupying, and it’s our responsibility to live up to their standards.”
The phones confirmed it. Friends from across the country flooded the team with texts, social media lit up, and reservations doubled immediately after the broadcast.
For Ard, who grew up in Boise and returned after more than 20 years away, walking out with a platter in front of 18,140 Bronco fans dressed head to toe in blue carried weight beyond the menu. “Bronco Nation is real,” he said. “I’m still vibing from it. It’s still electric.”