After a community book fair on Oct. 18, the owner of Austen’s Shelf says she was driven to tears by harassment that included screaming confrontations, threats of bureaucratic retaliation, and allegations that neighbors poured bleach and vinegar outside her Bordentown City storefront while invoking witchcraft.
Charity Herndon, who opened the brick-and-mortar location in June after launching as a mobile bookseller in a 7-by-14-foot trailer last September, detailed the fallout in a social media video posted last week. She said people screamed at her mother over the street closure the event required.
Neighbors later warned her that “witches in the town” were “casting spells over my business so it can’t do well, and pouring vinegar outside of it, and bleach,” Herndon said in the post. “This was all very overwhelming and I spent all weekend in tears,” she said. Herndon added that neighbors told her she had upset “powerful people” in town who could create ordinances to make future events harder.
Deputy Mayor Jennifer Sciortino responded on social media, distancing city government from the alleged intimidation.

“I want to clear — whoever these ‘powerful people’ are, they are not affiliated with city government or supported by it,” Sciortino wrote. “I am embarrassed and infuriated by the allegations that have surfaced. I’m also heartbroken for the small business owner who has been hurt, alienated, and disenfranchised by the racism and small-mindedness she has faced.”
Mayor Stephanie Lagos told Herndon she would work to create ordinances that make it easier to hold reading-centered events, according to Herndon’s post. On Friday, Lagos, Sciortino and Commissioner Grace Archer released a joint statement: “The recent allegations of racism, discrimination, and intimidation involving members of our community are deeply concerning, and we want to be clear: Racism, discrimination and exclusion have no place in Bordentown City.”
The commissioners said the Nov. 30 public commission work session will be used for a downtown business community roundtable so owners can share their experiences directly with the city.
Herndon said she is moving her holiday market to Sabrina’s Event Space in Berlin rather than holding it at the store because of the short notice for approval and the fallout from the October fair. Herndon, Lagos and Sciortino did not immediately respond to requests for comment Saturday.