In a column for The Art of Manliness, Brett McKay argues that the disappearance of the Oklahoma Drill from football fields across the country mirrors a broader cultural failure to replace risky male rites of passage with meaningful alternatives.
McKay opens with a scene from seventh grade at Sequoyah Middle School in Edmond, Oklahoma. It was the first day of pads, a sweltering August afternoon, and the coach had arranged the team in a circle around a narrow chute of tackling dummies.
For 45 minutes, three 13-year-old boys at a time stepped into the arena while teammates whooped and let out a collective “OOOOOOOHHHHHH!!” after every vicious hit. McKay writes that he waited with butterflies and sweaty palms, studying his peers to avoid looking like an idiot — or dying.
His turn came at defender. The blocker was smaller, but the ball carrier was Evan, a Little League teammate who already had a beard and visible deltoids while McKay wore “husky” underwear from Sears. Evan did not juke.
He railroaded him. Helmets popped. The crowd roared. McKay saw stars, hit the turf, and wondered if he was paralyzed. He got up fast, cracked a self-deprecating joke, and took his place in the ring. Welcome to football.
The drill traces to Bud Wilkinson, who took over at the University of Oklahoma in 1947 and installed a 5-2 defense that required interior linemen to control two gaps. Wilkinson, a veteran of the Navy’s V-5 pre-flight program, used boxing and wrestling to weed out cadets who lacked aggression.
He imported that logic to Norman. The Oklahoma Drill became a sorting tool: who has the dog in them? From 1953 to 1957, the Sooners won 47 straight games, still the college record. The drill spread to the NFL, college programs, high schools, and peewee leagues.
Coaches loved it for technique, but mostly as a man-maker. Vince Lombardi saw it as a measure of manhood. Bill Belichick boiled it to three questions: “Who is a man? Who’s tough? Who’s going to hit somebody?”
Barry Switzer called it “one of the few Neanderthal drills that I still believe in. You learn all you need to know about a player and you learn it in a hurry.” When masculine reputation is on the line, McKay writes, boys will put their hat on the other guy’s hat as hard as they can.
That is also a good way to get injured. High-profile cases of severe injury and death prompted a push to ban it. Research on chronic traumatic encephalopathy showed that cumulative sub-concussive hits — the kind the drill produces by the dozens — drive CTE risk as much as diagnosed concussions.
The NFL banned the drill in 2019. The NCAA followed in 2021. Both concluded the straight-line collisions rarely happen in games. USA Football now tells youth and high school programs to drop it.
Many coaches have swapped in rugby-style tackling drills that teach shoulder contact and head placement. Yet the drill lives on in social media: beach versions with no pads, co-ed iterations, even amateur competitions with weight classes and rankings. The same “OOOOOHHHHHH!” echoes in the comments.
McKay admits ambivalence. Getting rid of it was probably the right call, but the drill viscerally taught him courage and that taking a hit — physical or psychological — often isn’t as bad as the anticipation. Young men need those lessons, and they are hard to teach safely. Across cultures, rites of passage inculcated bravery, resilience, and pain endurance.
They answered a young man’s desire to test and prove himself. Society now wants challenges without risk or pain that still feel significant. That is impossible. As risk drops, so does significance. You could make BUD/S training so safe that no one dies, but it would stop being transformative.
The Art of Manliness began in 2008 when Brett McKay built the site himself using self-taught code. Eighteen years later it has expanded into an ecosystem the McKays call McKay Inc., comprising the flagship site, the Strenuous Life — a scouting-style program for grown men — and Dying Breed, a Substack newsletter for more personal essays.
A 2019 redesign introduced the tagline “Get Action,” lifted from a young Teddy Roosevelt’s journal, shifting emphasis from information to implementation.
How to balance the risk-reward ratio so the experience isn’t needlessly reckless but still means enough to change a young man is a hard nut to crack. We have removed the Oklahoma Drill. We haven’t figured out what to put in its place.