Brown Study: Medicare Data Change May Inflate Dialysis Center Ratings

A change in how Medicare collects patient data could make hundreds of dialysis centers look better on paper without a single improvement in care, Brown University researchers reported Monday.

The shift took effect in July 2025, when the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services stopped collecting race and ethnicity information on several federal forms, including the End-Stage Renal Disease Medical Evidence Report completed when patients begin dialysis treatment.

Researchers simulated the removal of race and ethnicity from the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) calculations that Medicare uses to rate dialysis facilities. The study, published in JAMA Internal Medicine, found that 27% of centers serving the highest proportions of Black patients moved into a better-performing category when those demographic factors were excluded.

Simultaneously, close to 22% of centers caring for the most socially disadvantaged patients climbed to a higher rank, whereas roughly 15% of centers with fewer disadvantaged patients dropped to a lower rank.

“Our study suggests that the removal of race and ethnicity data is going to have a significant impact on a number of dialysis facilities and how they’re being scored in this model, so we wanted people to understand that going forward,” said Kalli Koukounas Green, lead author and a research scientist at Brown’s Department of Health Services, Policy and Practice.

“A patient might see these new mortality ratings and make their referral decision based on that, not knowing that the more favorable rating is due to a modeling change.”

The research team examined data from 6,895 dialysis centers nationwide between 2017 and 2020. They calculated facility ratings first with race and ethnicity included in the risk-adjustment model, then without it. Facilities treating more patients who face social or economic disadvantages generally earned poorer scores when race and ethnicity were factored in; once those details were omitted, the rating gap between those centers and ones serving fewer disadvantaged patients all but vanished.

“These mortality measures and these kinds of relative performance rankings for dialysis facilities are important and have high-stakes consequences,” said Dr. Amal Trivedi, senior author and a professor of health services, policy and practice and of medicine at Brown. The researchers noted the findings are particularly relevant for physicians who use the ratings to make referrals and for facilities that use them to guide quality-improvement investments.

The study acknowledged limitations: it used older data to estimate future effects because the actual impact of CMS’s new data-collection practices on published ratings is not yet known. The authors called for future research to examine how much facility ratings actually change once the new practices are reflected in Medicare’s public reports.