BYU and West Virginia Battle to a Draw in Thrilling Soccer Match

The BYU women’s soccer team saw their lead vanish in the final seconds of regulation, ultimately settling for a 1-1 draw against West Virginia on November 9, 2026.

The result, confirmed by official Big 12 Conference box scores, leaves both squads grappling with the reality of a hard-fought stalemate that extended deep into overtime.

BYU dictated much of the early momentum, striking first at the 13:18 mark. Sophie Sivulich netted her third goal of the season, capitalizing on precise setup work from teammates Lucy Kesler and Mia Goettsche. For over 75 minutes, that singular goal stood as the difference, with the Cougars’ defense and goalkeeping tandem of Chelsea Peterson and Paiton Collins holding firm against a persistent Mountaineer attack.

The match turned on a dramatic sequence in the final minute of regulation. With the clock reading 89:52, West Virginia’s Maya Leoni found the back of the net to tie the score at 1-1. That late-game goal forced the contest into overtime, where neither side could break the deadlock despite a combined 35 shots throughout the evening.

Statistic	West Virginia	BYU
Total Shots	24	11
Shots on Goal	5	4
Saves	3	4
Corner Kicks	4	6

West Virginia’s offensive pressure was relentless throughout the match, recording 24 total shots compared to BYU’s 11. Despite the volume of attempts, the Mountaineers struggled to translate that pressure into efficiency, putting only five of those shots on target. BYU’s goalkeepers remained composed under the heavy load, with Paiton Collins logging 65 minutes and four saves to keep the Cougars in contention.

The physical nature of the Big 12 matchup was evident in the officiating, as the referee issued a yellow card to BYU’s Mika Krommenhoek at the 58:42 mark. The match saw a flurry of substitutions as both coaching staffs attempted to inject fresh energy into the lengthy, 110-minute affair. By the time the final whistle blew, the intensity of the conference play had clearly taken its toll on both rosters.

This draw impacts the standing of both programs as they look to close out their campaigns. BYU entered the match with a 12-3-4 record and 8-1-2 in conference play, while West Virginia stood at 9-4-5 overall. The result highlights the parity within the Big 12, where even a dominant defensive performance can be erased by a single opportunistic strike in the closing seconds.

For West Virginia, the ability to find an equalizer in the 90th minute serves as a testament to their persistence, particularly given their high shot count throughout the game. Conversely, BYU will likely rue the missed opportunity to close out the win in regulation, having held the lead for the vast majority of the match.

Neither team could find the decisive play needed to break the stalemate in the ensuing overtime periods, leaving the final score as a reflection of a balanced, albeit frustrating, defensive battle.