CFP Committee Ranks Alabama at No. 3 and Drops Indiana to No. 9

CFP Committee Ranks Alabama at No. 3 and Drops Indiana to No. 9

by

The College Football Playoff selection committee has sparked intense debate by ranking two-loss Alabama at No. 3, while dropping idle Indiana five spots to No. 9. Despite a head-to-head loss to Tennessee, Alabama remains the highest-ranked two-loss team, fueled by metrics the committee insists validate the Crimson Tide’s strength of schedule.

Why is Alabama ranked at No. 3?

The selection committee’s decision to place Alabama at No. 3 relies heavily on the team’s strength of schedule and a collection of “quality wins.” Hunter Yurachek, the selection committee chairman, pointed specifically to an early-season victory against Mississippi State as a primary factor, noting the Bulldogs were 4-0 at the time of the matchup. Yurachek stated on ESPN that the committee believes Alabama deserves to be the No. 3 team in the country.

Alabama currently sits at 3-2 against the committee’s top 25, boasting victories over Kentucky, South Carolina, and LSU. While the team suffered a 26-10 defeat at the hands of Tennessee, the committee continues to prioritize the Tide’s No. 1 ranked schedule strength. The committee's rankings differ from the AP Poll, which places Alabama four spots lower than the CFP committee.

How did Indiana fall during a bye week?

Indiana’s drop from the top tier of the rankings while on a bye week represents the largest such slide in the 13-year history of the College Football Playoff. The Hoosiers fell five spots to No. 9, a move Yurachek attributed to the timing of their idle week and the outcomes of games involving other top contenders.

“They were probably a victim of having a bye week at the wrong time,” Yurachek said Tuesday. The lack of movement from Big Ten opponents on Indiana’s schedule—who combined for an 0-8 record last week—further complicated their standing in the eyes of the committee. Indiana will look to rebound on Saturday when they host No. 18 USC in Bloomington.

Is the SEC receiving preferential treatment?

The committee’s current methodology has placed a heavy emphasis on strength-of-conference data, leading to a crowded top 25 for the SEC. Currently, nine SEC teams occupy spots in the rankings, with seven of those teams positioned higher than they appear in the AP Poll. Critics point to the inclusion of Missouri and LSU—both of which have winless records against top-25 opponents—as evidence of the committee’s reliance on strength-of-conference data.

Missouri, for instance, remains ranked despite being 0-2 against the top 25 and suffering a 14-point home loss to Texas on Saturday. Meanwhile, teams from outside the SEC, such as New Mexico and Boise State, have seen their rankings lower than those assigned by AP voters. New Mexico, which leads the nation in scoring defense, remains unranked by the committee despite an 8-1 record.

Can Tennessee or Notre Dame secure a bye?

Tennessee sits at No. 8, despite owning a head-to-head victory over Alabama and a dominant four-touchdown win over No. 11 Kentucky this past Saturday. While the committee’s protocol lists head-to-head results as the second principle for evaluating comparable teams, the gap between the Vols and the Tide remains five spots. Tennessee faces a challenging road ahead, with a game at Texas A&M on Saturday and a matchup against LSU on Nov. 21.

Notre Dame, meanwhile, vaulted from No. 11 to No. 5 following their win over then-No. 1 Miami.

No team in the history of the CFP Rankings had gone from outside the top 10 into the top five in one week. Despite the historic rise, the Irish remain on the outside looking in for a first-round bye.

Without a conference championship game to help their resume, Notre Dame must rely on losses from teams currently ranked above them to climb into the top four. The Irish close out their regular season against Boston College, SMU, and Syracuse.

More on this story: CFP Rankings Shift Following Weekend of College Football Games · CFP Committee Ranks Tennessee Behind Alabama Despite Win, USA Today

More on Alabama: Alabama Could Reach CFP First-Round Bye as Texas Nears Top-Four Seed · Alabama defeats LSU in Baton Rouge to boost playoff playoff odds · Alabama Beats LSU 31-13, Dropping Tigers to No. 24 in AP Poll

Alabama Is #5 After Losing to Tennessee… The CFP Committee Has a Problem? — Dappz Sports

Related reading

Read next