Eleven years after a white supremacist killed nine Black parishioners during Bible study at the South’s oldest African Methodist Episcopal church, a marble courtyard opened Saturday in Charleston to honor the Emanuel Nine, The Christian Science Monitor reported.
The dedication on Nov. 14 drew survivors, victims’ families, and the architect who also designed the National September 11 Memorial. Michael Arad’s winning concept — chosen from more than 5,000 entries for the World Trade Center site — carries the same title here: “Reflecting Absence.”
At the center sits the Fountain of Grace, a shallow basin with a cross-shaped opening where water flows over the names of the six women and three men slain on June 17, 2015. Two Fellowship Benches curve like wings around the pool, and a Cross of Hope stands nearby. A Survivors’ Garden, with five trees and benches for the living witnesses and a sixth for the church itself, is planned next.
“When people walk through … I don’t want them to only feel sorrow. I want them to feel a spark.”
Polly Sheppard, one of five survivors, told the gathering, her papers fluttering in the Atlantic wind. “It’s time to clear out the hatred, the racism, the division, and replace it with empathy, forgiveness, and enduring love,” she said.

A design born from listening
The Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation did not ask finalists for renderings. Instead, candidates answered written questions about forgiveness — a prompt Arad called prescient. A white, Jewish New Yorker who had never visited South Carolina, he spent more than a year in conversation with congregants and studying the church’s 200-year history, including the 1822 slave revolt led by a founder.
“In both instances, we tried to create places that welcome people in, that create a public realm that can act to bring us together and give us a sense of identity through community,” Arad said at the ribbon-cutting. “We [don’t] confront these tragedies alone, but in the presence of others.”
Forgiveness, but not uniformity
Chris Singleton, whose mother, the Rev. Sharonda Coleman-Singleton, died in the shooting, was a high-school student in 2015.
Less than 24 hours later he said of the 21-year-old gunman, “we are forgiving him.” At the memorial he added a heavier truth: “When people go through stuff, especially young men, we’re expected to pack it down, and just get by. [Men] need hugs, too. We need to let it out, too. … Stop pretending like it’s not affecting you.”
Deona Smith, the foundation’s executive director, cautioned against a single narrative. “I’ve learned over the years to never speak for the families and survivors. They are not monolithic and are at different stages of the grieving process,” she wrote in an email.
Alana Grant, granddaughter of the Rev. Daniel Lee Simmons, avoided the church basement for years. Now she sees the courtyard as a place to introduce her three children to their great-grandfather’s story before they hear it elsewhere. “I do want them to go so that they can kind of see what even brought me to South Carolina,” she said.

Former North Carolina state senator Malcolm Graham, whose sister Cynthia Graham Hurd died under a desk in the fellowship hall, said a library and scholarship already carry her name. “She is the most famous person in our family and I still look up to her,” he said.
Separate entities, shared purpose
The church and the Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation operate independently, though Rev. Eric Manning, who succeeded the slain pastor and state Sen. Clementa Pinckney, co-chairs the foundation board. “Just for a moment, a peace came over me,” Manning said after standing in the courtyard.
The Mother Emanuel Memorial Foundation, an independent 501(c)(3) nonprofit, was formed by community and business leaders in the weeks after the 2015 tragedy to build, preserve, and maintain the memorial campus on Calhoun Street. Its board bridges the broader Charleston community with church representatives, and it develops educational resources and reconciliation programs rooted in the congregation’s history. Deona Smith serves as executive director.
The memorial opens to the public daily. The Survivors’ Garden has no completion date yet.
Worth a look
- Brake Rotor Tears From Tractor-Trailer, Kills Driver on I-84 in Tolland
- UNL Student Arrested on Sexual Assault Warrant Seven Months After Campus Dorm Rape Report
- Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning her sons in a South Carolina lake (newsarchyuk.com)
- Kinale Girls Wins East African Rugby Title, Supplied Nine Players to Kenya Youth Olympic Gold Squad (world-today-news.com)